1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

Intervention

Study Design

Population

Outcomes

Author, Year

N

Statistically Significant

Quality of Study

(GRADE)

Magnitude of Benefit

Absolute Risk Reduction

Comments

Risk of

Bias

Online learning vs. face-to-face learning

Cross-sectional design; quantitative and qualitative

Graduate-level online students/MBA students

Online courses offer students more flexibility than face-to-face.

Evans, 2013

225-survey, 10 interviews

yes

moderate

medium

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding

Low

Online learning vs. face-to-face learning

Quasi-experimental post-test

Graduate-level online students

does technology improve teaching and learning

Groeling, 2004

180 students

yes

low

small

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding, lack of description of withdrawals and dropouts

Low

Online learning

Survey-based

graduate and undergraduate online students

Are online students satisfied with online classes, yes

Hamrick, 2004

360 students

yes

high

small

n/a

lack of blinding, lack of description of withdrawals and dropouts

Low

Online learning and teaching

Instructional design

graduate and undergraduate students

effect of new technologies used in teaching and learning

Hegngi, 1997

10

n/a

low

small

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding

Low

Distance education

Survey-based

graduate and undergraduate online students

which of the 15 steps procedure are important for the success of distance education courses

Henckell, 2007

430

yes

high

medium

n/a

lack of blinding

Low

Student engagement in online discussions

One-way repeated measures analysis of variance; survey-based

undergrad, grad and doctorate students

to determine problems with online threaded discussions in higher education

Holland, 2006

11 from actual study

yes

moderate

small

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding, lack of description of withdrawals and dropouts

Low

Online learning faculty training

Mixed methods study (quantitative and qualitative); survey-based

graduate level online faculty

to determine the needs of faculty members in order to be successful

Hwu, 2011

93

yes

moderate

medium

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding

Low

Technical support and pedagogical guidance in online learning

Quantitative methods

graduate level online faculty and students

factors that influence faculty satisfaction, technical support and pedagogical guidance and student satisfaction

Ice, 2006

15 instructors, 519 students

yes

moderate

medium

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding, lack of description of withdrawals and dropouts

Low

Online graduate students support needs

Survey based

graduate level online students

to determine whether adult distant learners need more or less support than other distant students.

Kahrhoff, 2005

42

yes

moderate

medium

n/a

no randomized study, lack of blinding, lack of description of withdrawals and dropouts

Low