Criteria

Response options

Quality issue

The aims of research is sufficiently explained

Yes = 1/No = 0

Rigor: to ensure the quality of the research methodology and the data collections and analysis

The research method is clearly reported

Yes = 1/No = 0

Rigor: to ensure the quality of the research methodology and the data collections and analysis

The data identification and collection is described

Yes = 1/No = 0

Rigor: to ensure the quality of the research methodology and the data collections and analysis

The method used to analyze data is clearly explained

Yes = 1/No = 0

Rigor: to ensure the quality of the research methodology and the data collections and analysis

The findings are clearly stated and provided with credible results and justified conclusions

Yes = 1/No = 0

Credibility: to ensure that the findings are valid and meaningful

The findings provided a valuable contributions to the research question

Yes = 1/No = 0

Relevance: to ensure the relevance of the study for the relationships between IT and Supply chain performance