Model

K

N

Point estimation

95%CI

Z-Value

Q-Value

I²

τ²

H1

Fixed effect

20

9410

0.3692

0.3516 - 0.3866

37.47***

255.41***

92.60%

0.0323

Random effect

20

9410

0.3362

0.2589 - 0.4092

8.08***

H2

Fixed effect

12

3915

−0.1478

(−0.1784) - (−0.1169)

−9.27***

172.93***

93.60%

0.047

Random effect

12

3915

−0.1313

(−0.2564) - (−0.0019)

−1.99*