CA

M1

M2

M3

M4

controlled variable

scale

0.047

0.036

0.029

0.020

Years

−0.031

−0.023

−0.006

−0.004

Direct effect

NVS

0.271***

0.332***

0.334***

0.311

Curve effect

(NVS)2

−0.244***

−0.248***

−0.247***

Regulatory effect

MDC* NVS

0.207**

0.173***

MDC* (NVS)2

0.196**

DW

1.586

1.696

1.608

1.682

R2

0.076

0.132

0.175

0.211

F

6.053***

8.330***

9.221***

9.694***