S/No

Model Type

Model Equation Form

Independent Variables

Model Parameter

Goodness of fit indices

Remark

1

Multiple Linear Regression

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2 + a 3 X 3 + a 4 X 4

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Dry Density

X 3 = Liquid Limit

X 4 = Plasticity Index

a 0 = −42.314

a 1 = −0.084

a 2 = 7.627

a 3 = 0.394

a 4 = −0.396

R 2 = 0.478

MSE = 178.62

RMSE = 13.37

Model

unacceptable

2

Simple Linear Regression

y = a o + a 1 X 1

X 1 = Water Content

a 0 = 57.040

a 1 = −0.423

R 2 = 0.478

MSE = 178.62

RMSE = 13.37

Model

unacceptable

3

Multiple Linear Regression

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Effective stress

a 0 = 35.628

a 1 = −0.238

a 2 = 0.036

R 2 = 0.510

MSE = 133.91

RMSE = 11.57

Model

unacceptable

4

Multiple Linear Regression

(Outlier removed)

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Effective stress

a 0 = 29.23

a 1 = −0.205

a 2 = 0.043

R 2 = 0.805

MSE = 40.612

RMSE = 6.37

Model acceptable

5

Multiple Quadratic Regression

(Outlier removed)

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2 + a 3 X 3 2 + a 4 X 4 2

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Effective stress

X 3 = Water Content

X 4 = Effective stress

a 0 = 66.497

a 1 = −1.098

a 2 = 0.0696

a 3 = 0.0049

a 4 = −7E−5

R 2 = 0.828

MSE = 46.03

RMSE = 6.785

Model acceptable

6

Multiple Linear Regression

(Outlier removed)

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2 + a 3 X 3 + a 4 X 4

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Liquid Limit

X 3 = Plasticity Index

X 4 = Effective stress

a 0 = 31.392

a 1 = −0.098

a 2 = −0.341

a 3 = 0.330

a 4 = −0.050

R 2 = 0.846

MSE = 41.232

RMSE = 6.421

Model acceptable

7

Multiple Power Regression

(Outlier removed)

y = a o X 1 a 1 X 2 a 2 X 2 a 3 X 4 a 4

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Liquid Limit

X 3 = Plasticity Index

X 4 = Effective stress

a 0 = 203.728

a 1 = −0.487

a 2 = −1.584

a 3 = 1.208

a 4 = 0.41

R 2 = 0.890

MSE = 29.37

RMSE = 5.419

Model acceptable

8

Multiple Power Regression

No Outlier

y = a o X 1 a 1 X 2 a 2

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Effective stress

a 0 = 175.797

a 1 = −0.833

a 2 = 0.286

R 2 = 0.861

MSE = 29.105

RMSE = 5.395

Model acceptable

9

Multiple Quadratic Regression

(Outlier removed)

y = a o + a 1 X 1 + a 2 X 2 + a 3 X 3 + a 4 X 4

X 1 = Water Content

X 2 = Effective stress

X 3 = Water Content

X 4 = Effective stress

a 0 = 66.497

a 1 = −1.098

a 2 = 0.0696

a 3 = 0.0049

a 4 = −7E−5

R 2 = 0.828

MSE = 46.03

RMSE = 6.785

Model acceptable