|   
  |       Whole sample (2003)  |       Reduced sample (2003)  |       Reduced sample (2007)  |    ||||||
|   
  |       1  |       2  |       3  |       4  |       5  |       6  |       7  |       8  |       9  |    
|   
  |       Linear  |       Stepwise  |       Robust  |       Linear  |       Stepwise  |       Robust  |       Linear  |       Stepwise  |       Robust  |    
|   LTDEBT  |       0.0000 (0.4297)  |       x  |       x  |       0.0000 (0.7110)  |       x  |       x  |       0.0000 (0.9035)  |       x  |       x  |    
|   ASSET_LOG  |       −0.0334  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0265  |       −0.0528  |       −0.0564  |       0.0226  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.3562)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.5850)  |       (0.1237)  |       (0.1402)  |       (0.6728)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   LEV  |       −0.0008  |       −0.0008  |       −0.001200  |       −0.0008  |       −0.0008  |       −0.0013  |       −0.0002  |       −0.0002  |       −0.0002  |    
|   
  |       (0.0004)  |       (0.0000)  |       (0.0000)  |       (0.0049)  |       (0.0003)  |       (0.0157)  |       (0.0794)  |       (0.0205)  |       (0.4438)  |    
|   BOARD_LOG  |       0.3957  |       0.4099  |       0.420700  |       0.3847  |       0.3931  |       0.4371  |       0.4280  |       0.4224  |       0.4155  |    
|   (0.0169)  |       (0.0019)  |       0.0037  |       (0.0590)  |       (0.0146)  |       (0.0136)  |       (0.0457)  |       (0.0058)  |       (0.0378)  |    |
|   NED_PERC  |       −0.3756  |       x  |       x  |       −0.4167  |       x  |       x  |       0.0951  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.1703)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.1899)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.7611)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   INED_PERC  |       −0.0769  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0150  |       x  |       x  |       −0.9915  |       −0.4432  |       −0.0292  |    
|   (0.8018)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.9696)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.0163)  |       (0.1152)  |       (0.9394)  |    |
|   BRDMEET  |       0.0038  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0031  |       x  |       x  |       0.0063  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.8226)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.8877)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.7242)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   INTERLOCKS  |       0.0150  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0003  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0123  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.6125)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.9935)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.6968)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   AUDIT_IND  |       −0.0025  |       −0.0035  |       −0.004200  |       −0.0037  |       x  |       x  |       0.0031  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.2603)  |       (0.0526)  |       (0.0402)  |       (0.1520)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.2712)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   AUDIT_MEET  |       0.0413  |       0.0417  |       0.041500  |       0.0490  |       0.0664  |       0.0589  |       0.0080  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.0914)  |       (0.0444)  |       (0.0743)  |       (0.1075)  |       (0.0011)  |       (0.0089)  |       (0.7469)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   NOMIN_IND  |       −0.0027  |       x  |       
  |       −0.0048  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0306  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.7449)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.6579)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.1030)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   COMPENS_IND  |       −0.0013  |       x  |       
  |       −0.0002  |       x  |       x  |       0.0003  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.4741)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.9204)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.9107)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   SIND_CHARGES  |       0.0079  |       x  |       
  |       0.0018  |       x  |       x  |       0.0014  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.7592)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.9507)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.8044)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   SIND_MEET  |       −0.0097  |       x  |       
  |       0.0135  |       x  |       x  |       0.0065  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.5103)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.4966)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.7155)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   SHAREHLDR  |       −0.0096  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0058  |       x  |       x  |       0.0018  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.0846)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.4481)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.6534)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   SHARE2_NUM  |       0.0008  |       x  |       
  |       −0.0039  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0051  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.9674)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.8669)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.7713)  |       
  |       
  |    |
|   BOWN  |       0.0041  |       0.0032  |       0.0023  |       0.0024  |       x  |       x  |       −0.0011  |       x  |       x  |    
|   (0.0769)  |       (0.0467)  |       (0.1935)  |       (0.4111)  |       
  |       
  |       (0.6293)  |       
  |       
  |    |