PSO variants

Linear channel

Nonlinear channel

MSE in dB

Convergence rate

MSE in dB

Convergence rate

Shi et al. [10] [11]

−57

80

−59

90

Chatterjee et al. [12]

−56

110

−59

120

Feng et al. [13] [14]

−38

50

−28

50

Lei et al. [15]

−54

250

−59

250

Zheng et al. [16]

−25

25

−25

25

Jia et al. [17]

−20

10

−18

10

PSO-TVW1

−60

120

−59

120

MP-PSO-TVW1

−60

50

−59

50

PSO-TVW2

−59

45

−59

50

PSO-TVW3

−67

50

−65

50

MP-PSO-TVW2

−60

27

−60

30

MP-PSO-TVW3

−70

45

−65

45