Author/Study [years] | Numbers | Survivorship | Follow up | Prosthesis design | Study design | Results |
MacIntosh et al. [1972] | 130 | 95% | 7 Years | MacIntosh vitallum | Prospective | Good clinical outcomes at short term follow up |
Mackinnon & Mamor et al. [1988] | 39 | 95% 90% | 5 Years 25 Years | St. Georg Sled | Retrospective | Better functional outcomes |
Kozinn & Scott et al. [1989, 1991] | 100 | 90% 83% 82% | 9 Years 10 Years 11 Years | Unicondylar knee | Prospective | Good clinical outcomes at 9 years follow up |
Squire & Callaghan et al. [1998] | 140 | 84% | 22 Years | Marmor knee | Prospective | Clinically and survival rates are better |
Murray et al. [1998] | 143 | 98% | 10 Years | Oxford phase 1 & 2 | Retrieval | Functional and clinical results are better |
Berger & Naudie et al. [2005] | 62 | 98% 96% | 10 Years 13 Years | Miller–Galante | Retrospective | Good results at follow up |
Pandit et al. [2006] | 547 | 97% 96% | 5 Years 10 Years | Oxford phase 3 | Retrospective | Higher survival rate with better functional outcome |