#

10 in NI (point of break transversely)

#

10 in Flush (corner of inside reinforcement)

r

S (To AFGROW)

S (ABAQUS)

r

S (To AFGROW)

S (ABAQUS)

0

0.000

1.000

58.752

0

0.000

1.000

15.361

1

0.301

0.747

43.910

1

0.108

1.177

18.088

2

0.553

0.513

30.117

2

0.217

0.932

14.319

3

0.865

0.347

20.408

3

0.340

0.808

12.408

4

1.127

0.229

13.465

4

0.464

0.721

11.080

5

1.392

0.158

9.265

5

0.597

0.650

9.989

6

1.656

0.108

6.333

6

0.730

0.603

9.264

7

1.924

0.075

4.390

7

0.862

0.561

8.623

8

2.184

0.055

3.223

8

0.994

0.536

8.226

9

2.445

0.041

2.392

9

1.126

0.512

7.867

10

2.707

0.035

2.067

10

1.257

0.499

7.667

11

2.968

0.023

1.339

11

1.389

0.487

7.487

12

3.230

0.019

1.137

12

1.521

0.482

7.404

13

1.652

0.477

7.333

14

1.784

0.476

7.317