| GROUP | EDEMA DEGREE* | PHOTOAGING DEGREE* |
| Sunscreen | 0.6a | 2.4c |
| Control gel base | 2.0b | 3.0d |
| Control without gel | 2.2b | 3.0d |
| 2% black pop bean | 0.2a | 2.0b |
| 5% black pop bean | 0.6a | 1.0a |
| 2% red pop bean | 0.2a | 2.0b |
| 5% red pop bean | 2.0b | 1.0a |