| 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | ||||
Area | Score | Rank | Area | Score | Rank | Area | Score | Rank |
Beijing | −0.8708 | 14 | −0.9109 | 10 | −0.82417 | 11 | −0.32732 | 12 |
Tianjin | −0.9408 | 17 | −0.6755 | 14 | −0.79291 | 14 | −0.88053 | 16 |
Hebei | −0.8068 | 16 | −0.8551 | 17 | −0.92349 | 17 | −0.99365 | 17 |
Shanxi | −1.8386 | 23 | −1.7824 | 22 | −1.85246 | 22 | −1.66747 | 23 |
Inner Mongolia | −1.9051 | 24 | −1.9123 | 24 | −1.95255 | 24 | −1.75559 | 24 |
Liaoning | −1.5769 | 20 | −0.6838 | 15 | −0.55329 | 15 | −1.35580 | 20 |
Jilin | −1.1869 | 18 | −1.21222 | 19 | −1.186144 | 19 | −1.28939 | 18 |
Heilongjiang | −1.14681 | 22 | 1.07014 | 21 | −1.0958 | 21 | −1.62588 | 22 |
Shanghai | 0.44844 | 11 | 0.73822 | 7 | 0.68685 | 7 | −0.12501 | 9 |
Jiangsu | 6.52389 | 2 | 6.94451 | 2 | 6.72942 | 2 | 9.77886 | 2 |
Zhejiang | 2.0813 | 4 | 2.22688 | 4 | 2.35884 | 4 | 1.74650 | 4 |
Anhui | 0.4433 | 7 | −0.12663 | 12 | 0.00789 | 12 | −0.04946 | 7 |
Fujian | 0.4599 | 6 | −0.1417 | 8 | −0.2144 | 8 | 0.18593 | 6 |
Jiangxi | −0.2567 | 12 | −0.2441 | 13 | −0.2871 | 13 | −0.59770 | 13 |
Shandong | 2.8926 | 3 | 2.7656 | 3 | 2.86395 | 3 | 2.15967 | 3 |
Henan | 0.7569 | 5 | 0.4996 | 6 | 0.77045 | 6 | 0.36569 | 5 |
Hubei | −0.1423 | 11 | −0.0331 | 9 | 0.10690 | 9 | −0.31066 | 11 |
Hunan | 0.1273 | 9 | −0.09853 | 11 | 0.047849 | 10 | −0.28423 | 10 |
Guangdong | 14.0240 | 1 | 12.37934 | 1 | 13.49664 | 1 | 14.61901 | 1 |
Guangxi | −1.2282 | 19 | −1.34103 | 20 | −1.273958 | 20 | −1.31891 | 9 |
Hainan | −2.2003 | 29 | −2.10835 | 27 | −2.202171 | 27 | −1.90839 | 28 |
Chongqing | −0.5461 | 13 | −1.16314 | 18 | −0.950924 | 18 | −0.71963 | 14 |
Sichuan | 0.1497 | 24 | 0.39331 | 24 | 0.289262 | 5 | −0.05410 | 8 |
Guizhou | −1.6921 | 21 | −1.90070 | 23 | −1.889755 | 23 | −1.52585 | 21 |
Yunnan | −2.0290 | 25 | −1.96673 | 25 | −2.051084 | 25 | −1.79386 | 25 |
Tibet | −2.2705 | 31 | −2.22929 | 31 | −2.301347 | 31 | −1.96615 | 31 |
Gansu | −2.0277 | 26 | −1.94005 | 26 | −1.939874 | 26 | −1.81064 | 26 |
Qinghai | −2.1986 | 30 | 2.20968 | 30 | −2.8465 | 30 | −1.92243 | 30 |
Ningxia | −2.1708 | 27 | −2.16429 | 28 | −2.043669 | 28 | −1.89110 | 27 |
Xinjiang | −2.1933 | 28 | −2.1759 | 29 | −2.03732 | 29 | −1.91172 | 29 |