2016

2017

2018

2019

Area

Score

Rank

Area

Score

Rank

Area

Score

Rank

Beijing

−0.8708

14

−0.9109

10

−0.82417

11

−0.32732

12

Tianjin

−0.9408

17

−0.6755

14

−0.79291

14

−0.88053

16

Hebei

−0.8068

16

−0.8551

17

−0.92349

17

−0.99365

17

Shanxi

−1.8386

23

−1.7824

22

−1.85246

22

−1.66747

23

Inner Mongolia

−1.9051

24

−1.9123

24

−1.95255

24

−1.75559

24

Liaoning

−1.5769

20

−0.6838

15

−0.55329

15

−1.35580

20

Jilin

−1.1869

18

−1.21222

19

−1.186144

19

−1.28939

18

Heilongjiang

−1.14681

22

1.07014

21

−1.0958

21

−1.62588

22

Shanghai

0.44844

11

0.73822

7

0.68685

7

−0.12501

9

Jiangsu

6.52389

2

6.94451

2

6.72942

2

9.77886

2

Zhejiang

2.0813

4

2.22688

4

2.35884

4

1.74650

4

Anhui

0.4433

7

−0.12663

12

0.00789

12

−0.04946

7

Fujian

0.4599

6

−0.1417

8

−0.2144

8

0.18593

6

Jiangxi

−0.2567

12

−0.2441

13

−0.2871

13

−0.59770

13

Shandong

2.8926

3

2.7656

3

2.86395

3

2.15967

3

Henan

0.7569

5

0.4996

6

0.77045

6

0.36569

5

Hubei

−0.1423

11

−0.0331

9

0.10690

9

−0.31066

11

Hunan

0.1273

9

−0.09853

11

0.047849

10

−0.28423

10

Guangdong

14.0240

1

12.37934

1

13.49664

1

14.61901

1

Guangxi

−1.2282

19

−1.34103

20

−1.273958

20

−1.31891

9

Hainan

−2.2003

29

−2.10835

27

−2.202171

27

−1.90839

28

Chongqing

−0.5461

13

−1.16314

18

−0.950924

18

−0.71963

14

Sichuan

0.1497

24

0.39331

24

0.289262

5

−0.05410

8

Guizhou

−1.6921

21

−1.90070

23

−1.889755

23

−1.52585

21

Yunnan

−2.0290

25

−1.96673

25

−2.051084

25

−1.79386

25

Tibet

−2.2705

31

−2.22929

31

−2.301347

31

−1.96615

31

Gansu

−2.0277

26

−1.94005

26

−1.939874

26

−1.81064

26

Qinghai

−2.1986

30

2.20968

30

−2.8465

30

−1.92243

30

Ningxia

−2.1708

27

−2.16429

28

−2.043669

28

−1.89110

27

Xinjiang

−2.1933

28

−2.1759

29

−2.03732

29

−1.91172

29