21

Pandit N S K (2006) [70]

India

274

6.2

Cross sectional study

All the patients who registered for DOT treatment during last quarter (Oct-Nov-Dec) 2002, in Anand district, state Gujarat, India

22

Daniel O J (2006) [64]

Nigeria

774

23

Retrospective cohort study

Adult Tuberculosis patients age 15 years and above registered for anti-TB treatment DOTS between January 1997-December 2003 , Sagamu, Nigeria

23

Estifanos B S (2007) [32]

Ethiopia

404

20

Prospective cohort study

Smear-positive tuberculosis patients in Hossana Hospital

24

Gelmanova I Y (2007) [43]

Russia

237

8.8

Retrospective cohort study

Detected, smear and/or culture-positive adult TB patients initiating therapy in a DOTS programme in Tomsk between 1 January and 31 December 2001

25

Fahrettin T (2008) [44]

Turkey

586

5.1

Retrospective cohort study

Adult pulmonary tuberculosis patient age more than 15 years in Istanbul Eyup tuberculosis Dispensary between year 1999-2004

26

Franke M F (2008) [50]

Peru

671

10

Retrospective cohort

Patients with multi drug resistant TB disease

27

Kapella B K (2009) [71]

Thailand

995

40

Cohort study

Registered TB treatment (non Thai) from 1 October 2004 to 31 September 2006.

28

Xu L (2010) [33]

China

501

9

A patient-based study survey

Rural smear-positive pulmonary TB patients registered with the county TB dispensaries at study sites who completed treatment during the period October 2006 to September 2007.

29

Kliiman K (2010) [65]

Estonia

1107

9.4

A retrospective cohort study

patients with culture-confirmed pulmonary TB who started treatment during 2003-2005

30

Samuel A B (2010) [72]

Ghana

165

55.7

Cross-sectional study

TB patients who had registered in New Juaben District from January 2003 to December 2005 (TB Registry) and had fully completed their treatment during the time of the study

31

Muture B N (2011) [45]

Kenya

1978

16.7

A Case-Control study

TB patients (adults and children) registered during the period January 2005 to March 2007

32

Kelly E D (2011) [51]

Morocco

291

13

A retrospective cohort study

Patients with smear- or culture-positive pulmonary tuberculosis

33

Finlay A (2012) [46]

South Africa

3165

12

retrospective case control study

Adult persons ≥ 18 years old enrolled in treatment under DOTS at public health facilities in South Africa between January 1 and December 31, 2002

34

Culqui D R (2012) [56]

Peru

789

5

An unmatched- case-control study

Patients diagnosed with tuberculosis from 2004 to 2005 who completed treatment until September 2006 in Peru

35

Garrido M D S (2012) [60]

Brazilia

11,321

10

Case control study

TB patients from 2005-2010 in the Amazonas State

36

Tamhane A (2012) [75]

India

150

29

Cross-sectional study

Newly diagnosed sputum smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) patients

37

Nezenega Z S (2013) [61]

Ethiopia

531

26

Cross sectional study

TB patients on anti TB treatment in 11 public health centers and one hospital of Sidama zone

38

Lalor M K (2013) [49]

Uzbekistan

710

20

A retrospective cohort

Multi and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis patients who started treatment between 2003 and 2008 and thus had finished approximately 2 years of treatment by the end of 2010

39

Slama K (2013) [39]

Morocco

320

33.8

Case-control study

TB patients (new cases or relapsed) who were enrolled in treatment for TB between 1 January 2009 and 31 December 2010