| Variables | Augmented Dickey-Fuller | Phillips-Perron | ||
| Origin | First Difference | Origin | First difference | |
| Opium | −2.255 | −17.806* | −1.698 | −18.886* |
| Tea | −1.34 | −9.664* | −1.29 | −9.749* |
| Silk | −1.686 | −11.274* | −1.349 | −12.126* |
| Silver Inflow | −4.471* | −15.34* | −4.452 | −15.938* |
| Silver-Copper Ratio | −1.636 | −7.254* | −2.092 | −7.325* |
| Rice Price | −2.345 | −10.825* | −2.135 | −1.127* |