EU

USA

Singapore

Overview of regulatory/supervisory bodies in the area of SCRM

Banking Regulation by EBA; Banking supervision by ECB/national supervisor

National banking authority & each state’s banking authority, e.g. FED and NYSDFS

Regulatory body and supervisory body unified by the MAS

Regulatory/supervisory system in the area of SCRM

Two independent functions

Not completely independent functions

Only one function

History of regulatory/supervisory system

World Financial Crisis in 2008 → Single Supervisory Mechanism of the EU

World Financial Crisis of 2008 → overregulation by new regulation & standards

Based on Asian approach & oriented on Western world

Guidelines issued in the area of SCRM and Outsourcing

Several regulations to follow

Several guidelines by multiple regulators & standard-setters

Strict and clear approach; Single point of truth

Application of guidelines in the field of Outsourcing

Self-assessment of each bank; Principle oriented nature

Self-assessment of each bank; Principle oriented nature

Self-assessment of each bank; Principle-oriented nature

Definition of “Outsourcing” and “service provider”

Outsourcing = process, service or activity that would be undertaken by the institution itself; service provider = third-party entity

Outsourcing = arrangements are limited to those listed in FED 13.19 service provider = third-party entity

Outsourcing = widest definition; even including intra-group arrangements service provider = including all entities that provide a service

Existence of standards

Standards exist

Standards are integral part of the regulatory program

Not required if not included in guidelines by MAS