Hassanein et al., 2021

Egypt

b

a

Theoretical session/ Structured simulation-based learning session

Knowledge test/ Attitude rating scale/ Observational skill-checklist

[86]

Huang et al., 2021

Taiwan Area

a

a

Mobile phone application with video clips

Knowledge test/ Observation of procedural skills

[87]

Balachander et al., 2021

India

b

a

Simulation with a newborn mannequin

Checklist score sheet/ Blood stream infection rate

[88]

Niyyar, 2021

US

b

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on simulation

Questionnaire for assessing procedural comfort and competency

[89]

Russell et al., 2021

US

b

a

Didactic lecture/ Hands-on practice session

Confidence assessment/ frequency tracker/ Intravenous access score/ Number of peripheral catheters

[90]

Filipovich et al., 2021

US

b

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on skills training

Knowledge test/ Confidence assessment

[91]

Divya et al., 2021

India

b

a

Lectures/ Practice demonstration

Knowledge test/ Observational checklist

[92]

Hackett et al., 2021

US

b

a

Didactic learning/ Simulation training/ Insertion validation.

Success rates of first-time insertions

[93]

Steinbauer et al., 2021

Austria

b

b

Lectures/ Simulation Training

Questionnaires

[94]

Amick et al., 2022

US

b

a

Instructional video/ Didactic lecture/ Hands-on practice using a simulator

Skill checklist/ Confidence assessment/ Numbers of successful catheter insertions

[95]

McKinney et al., 2022

US

b

a

Didactic lecture/ Simulation

Confidence level/ Knowledge test/ Proficiency test

[96]

Scimò et al., 2022

France

c

a

Theoretical training/ Observation/ Supervised and unsupervised insertions

Patient pain using a VAS/ Amount of PICC inserted/ Insertion time

[97]

Anderson et al., 2022

US

c

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on session

Success rate of the catheter placement/ Comfort and confidence assessment

[98]

Amick et al., 2022

US

c

a

Instructional video/ Recorded lecture/ Practice on simulator/ Supervised insertions on patients

Checklist for skills/ Numbers of ultrasound-guided peripheral intravenous catheter insertion

[99]

Bhargava et al., 2022

US

b

a

Presentation on ultrasound basics/ Hands-on practice with a vessel simulator

Stick success rate of peripheral intravenous placement

[100]

van Loon et al., 2022

Netherlands

c

a

Theoretical training/ Hands-on training/ Supervised life-case training

Knowledge test/ Successful attempts/ Number of successful cannulations and the time taken to perform them

[101]

Mousavi et al., 2022

Iran

c

a

Messages on PIVC placement sent by short message service

Knowledge test/ Observational skill assessment

[102]

Nonas et al., 2022

US

b

b

Didactic session/ Hands-on practice with high-tech mannequins/ Learning in the ICU

Knowledge test/ Course assessment

[103]