Ramsey et al., 2018

US

b

b

Lecture/ Simulation

Comfort level/ Knowledge test

[65]

Feinsmith et al., 2018

US

b

a

Didactic course/ Hands-on course using a vascular-access model

Numbers and rates of successful attempts

[66]

Adams et al., 2018

US

b

d

Didactic session/ Hands-on training with abscess model

Confidence level/ Assessment of the educational utility

[67]

Garner et al., 2018

US

b

a

Oral instruction/ Simulation using a low-fidelity equipment

Knowledge test/ Skills checklist

[68]

Han et al., 2018

Korea

b

b

Lecture/ Simulation

Self-efficacy assessment/ Clinical performance assessment

[69]

Leeper et al., 2018

US

b

b

Didactic lectures/ Hands-on skills training/ High-fidelity simulations

Course evaluation assessment/ Knowledge assessment

[70]

Lengetti et al., 2018

US

a

c

Self-paced learning modules/ Individualized feedback and correctives from an expert nurse

Skill checklist/ Self-regulation assessment

[71]

Ostrowski et al., 2019

US

c

a

Didactic module (slide and videos)/ Simulation session

The time required for catheter insertion/ CRNA’s evaluation

[72]

Covington et al., 2019

US

b

b

Online educational module/ Simulation using low-fidelity mannequins

Knowledge test/ Self-efficacy assessment

[73]

Short et al., 2019

US

b

b

Lecture/ Hands-on skills

Confidence level for knowledge and skill

[74]

Bortman et al., 2019

US

b

a

Online self-paced didactic component/ Integrated proctored hands-on workshops

Course assessment/ Knowledge test

[75]

Garcia-Gasalla et al, 2019

Spain

b

a

Peripheral venous catheter infection prevention bundle

Rates of peripheral venous catheter-associated bloodstream infection

[76]

Laghezza et al., 2019

US

b

b

Instruction sessions/ Demonstration/ Practice on simulators

Online-knowledge test/ Skill tests

[77]

Askey & Clements, 2019

Australia

c

a

Education component/ Practical component

Insertion success rate/ Correct line tip positioning

[78]

Stuckey & Curtis, 2019

US

c

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on session

Success rate for the catheter attempts

[79]

Lakhkar & Damake, 2019

India

b

a

Not described in detail

Numbers of the intravenous insertions/ Complications

[80]

Galen et al., 2020

US

b

a

Instructional video/ Practice using a mannequin

Number of the catheters/ Success rates of the catheters

[81]

Kadhim & Mhabes, 2020

Iraq

b

b

Education program (e.g. guided group discussion and role playing)/ Practices

Observational checklist

[82]

Elsobkey et al., 2020

Egypt

b

a

Knowledge session/ Performance session

Knowledge test/ Number, duration and success rate of the attempts/ Pain rating scale

[83]

Azizian et al., 2020

Iran

c

b

Education video/ Immediate feedback provided by the researcher

Checklist for assessing nurses’ endotracheal suctioning practices

[84]

Kadhim & Mhabes, 2021

Iraq

b

b

Lectures/ Practices

Knowledge test

[85]