Ault et al., 2015

US

c

a

1:1 mentoring sessions including didactic session/ Hands-on training session/ Live patients

Number of successful intravenous placements/ Time taken for successful vessel cannulation

[47]

Stephenson et al., 2015

US

c

b

Web-based didactic approach/ Simulation

Knowledge test/ Skill checklist/ Lasater clinical judgment rubric

[48]

Maeda et al., 2015

Japan

c

c

Didactic lecture

Questionnaires to measure satisfaction, learning achievement, and usefulness

[49]

Schade et al., 2015

US

b

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on session

Knowledge test/ Observational evaluation/ Assessment of psycho-motor domain

[50]

Adhikari et al., 2015

US

c

a

Didactic lecture session/ Practical session

Confidence and comfort level/ Direct observation

[51]

Kaur et al., 2015

India

a

b

Not described in detail

Knowledge and skill scores

[52]

Oliveira & Lawrence, 2016

US

c

a

Didactic session/ Hands-on session

Success rates, number of attempts, and complications after training

[53]

Kuszajewski et al., 2016

US

b

b

Practice using a mannequin and simulation scenario/ Intubation of live patients under the supervision

Knowledge test/ Endotracheal intubation checklist/ Self-confidence survey

[54]

Crous & Armstrong, 2016

South Africa

b

a

Watching a video/ Group discussion

Observational checklists

[55]

Keleekai et al., 2016

US

a

a

Self-paced online education/ Simulation-based live training

Knowledge assessment/ Confidence assessment/ Skill checklist

[56]

Meska et al., 2016

Brazil

b

c

Theoretical session/ Practice session using a low-fidelity simulator

Self-confidence scale

[57]

Vinayaka & Bernet, 2016

India

b

b

Not described in detail

Knowledge test/ Observational checklist

[58]

Jayalaxmi et al., 2016

India

b

a

Structured teaching program using demonstration on mannequin, charts and slides

Knowledge test/ Observational checklist

[59]

Harjot et al., 2016

India

b

b

Not described in detail

Knowledge test/ Observational checklist

[60]

Gosselin et al., 2016

Canada

b

a

Theory session/ Practice lab session

Cost of inserting the ultrasound-guided peripheral venous access

[61]

Glover et al., 2017

US

c

a

Self-paced interactive e-learning instruction/ Simulation-based practice

Skills Checklist/ Knowledge test

[62]

Gopalasingam et al., 2017

Denmark

b

a

E-learning course/ Practice using gelatin phantoms/ Supervised catheterizations

Number of catheters used/ Success rate of catheters placements

[63]

Morgaonkar et al., 2017

India

b

a

Interactive lecture for knowledge/ Hands-on training on manikins for skills

Skill checklist/ Knowledge test

[64]