Author/Year

Country/Area

Design

Procedure

Program

Assessment

Ref.

Day et al., 2001

UK

a

b

Didactic and interactive approaches/Practical bedside demonstration

Knowledge-based questionnaire/ Non-participant observation

[29]

Chang et al., 2002

China

a

a

Lecture/Skill learning

Checklist to assess/State-trait anxiety inventory/ Semi-structured interview

[30]

Ozyazicioğlu & Arikan, 2008

Türkiye

b

a

Lecture session/Question & answer session/ Booklets

Observation form

[31]

Tsai et al., 2008

Taiwan Area

a

a

Virtual reality simulation system

Knowledge test/Satisfaction assessment of the training

[32]

Day et al., 2009

UK

a

b

Performance feedback (Simulation & Clinical setting)

Knowledge test/Observation

[33]

Anson et al., 2010

US

b

a

Web-based online tutorial program

Self-assessment of knowledge, attitudes and practice

[34]

Banks et al., 2010

US

b

a

Multifaceted educational program (Self-study module/ Skills laboratory/Journal club)

Knowledge test/Confidence assessment/Educational modality

[35]

Avelar et al., 2010

Brazil

c

a

Theoretical session/Practice session

Knowledge/Skills/Ability to identify arteries/Positioning of catheters

[36]

Wilfong et al., 2011

US

a

a

Simulation training

Number of tries the nurse needed to successfully insert an intravenous

[37]

Chee et al., 2011

Australia

c

a

Theoretical session/Practical demonstration and practice session using simulation arms

Success rates of cannulations/ Participants’ assessment of the training program

[38]

Schneider, 2012

UK

b

c

Educational posters/Lectures with handouts

Knowledge test/Number of bladder infections

[39]

Lyons et al., 2012

US

b

a

Didactic instruction session/ Practice session using a computer simulation haptic device and mannequins

Knowledge test/ Skill test/ Confidence levels

[40]

Altun, 2012

Türkiye

b

a

Interactive lecture-based workshop

Knowledge test using a questionnaire

[41]

Moore, 2013

US

c

a

Didactic and hands-on course/ 1-on-1 individualized instruction with a nurse champion

Success rate of Ultrasound-guided peripheral intravenous line

[42]

Hadian & Sabet, 2013

Iran

b

b

Lecture/ Films/ Demonstration

Skill checklist/ Premature infant pain profile

[43]

Dorton et al., 2014

US

b

b

Online self-paced lecture/ Simulation laboratory session with the patient simulator

Comfort level/ Knowledge test

[44]

Blackman et al., 2014

Australia

b

a

E-learning

Questionnaire relating to knowledge and skill

[45]

Craft et al., 2014

US

c

a

Simulation-based training with a mannequin simulator

Performance checklist

[46]