Topic

Importance of the study

Literature review

Theoretical model

Empirical model

Conclusion

References³

Writing quality

Due Date

Is topic

interesting and timely?

Is relevance well-explained?

Are market failures listed and explained?

Is relevant

literature

presented?

If theoretical model is missing, propose one. Economics

mistakes should be pointed out.

If empirical model is missing, propose one. Is empirical model

testing what

theoretical model predicts?

Is there a

logical

conclusion to the paper?

Does author provide full citations and clear references in the text?

Is paper well

written?

Missing due date on peer review may result in 10 - 100 point deduction