| Parameters |
Wireless Technologies |
||||||||||
| GSM-R |
P25 |
TETRA |
802.11 |
WIMAX |
3G |
LTE-R |
RoF |
LCX |
Satellite |
FLASH-OFDM |
|
| Working Frequency |
800 - 900 MHz |
700 MHz |
~400 MHz |
2.4/5.8 GHz |
2.3/2.4/2.5/3.5 GHz |
800/910 MHz 2.1 GHz |
Variable 400 - 3.5 GHz |
Variable |
Variable |
Limited |
450 MHz and variable |
| Data Rate |
5 - 10 Kbps |
40 - 100 Kbps |
5 - 10 Kbps |
>10 Mbps |
>30 Mbps |
>2 Mbps (stationary) >384 Kbps (Mobile) |
>10 Mbps |
1 - 10 Gbps |
1 - 10 Mbps |
>2 Mbps |
>2 Mbps |
| IP Support |
Not standalone |
No |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Handover Mechanism |
Open standard (till 500 km/h) |
Open standard |
Open standard |
Proprietary |
Open standard/High handover |
Open standard |
Open |
Open; |
Open |
Depends |
Proprietary; |
| Modulation/ Multiplexing |
GMSK -TDMA |
4FSK |
DQPSK-TDMA |
QPSK, QAM |
BPSK, QPSK 16 QAM |
PSK |
QPSK, 16 - 64 QAM (OFDM, SCFDMA) |
QPSK, 16QAM-OFDM |
Standard and OFDM |
FSK-PSK |
OFDM |
| Maturity |
Mature, supporteduntil 2025 |
Mature in US |
Mature |
Mature |
Mature, lead to WIMAX 2 |
Mature |
Emerging and offered |
Concepts like “moving cell” |
Matured (N700) |
Matured but costly |
Matured |
| Market Support |
Until 2025 |
US |
Yes/almost obsolete |
Yes |
Yes, decreasing |
Yes, but moving to LTE |
Yes, building standards |
Matured |
Japan, Europe |
Yes, in Europe Thalys, SNCF |
Yes, Flarion |