Parameters

Wireless Technologies

GSM-R

P25

TETRA

802.11

WIMAX

3G

LTE-R

RoF

LCX

Satellite

FLASH-OFDM

Working

Frequency

800 - 900

MHz

700 MHz

~400 MHz

2.4/5.8 GHz

2.3/2.4/2.5/3.5 GHz

800/910 MHz

2.1 GHz

Variable 400 - 3.5 GHz

Variable

Variable

Limited

450 MHz and variable

Data Rate

5 - 10 Kbps

40 - 100 Kbps

5 - 10 Kbps

>10 Mbps

>30 Mbps

>2 Mbps (stationary)

>384 Kbps (Mobile)

>10 Mbps

1 - 10 Gbps

1 - 10 Mbps

>2 Mbps

>2 Mbps

IP

Support

Not standalone

No

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Handover

Mechanism

Open standard

(till 500 km/h)

Open standard

Open standard

Proprietary

Open standard/High

handover

Open standard

Open

Open;

Open

Depends

Proprietary;

Modulation/ Multiplexing

GMSK -TDMA

4FSK

DQPSK-TDMA

QPSK, QAM

BPSK, QPSK

16 QAM

PSK

QPSK, 16 - 64 QAM (OFDM, SCFDMA)

QPSK, 16QAM-OFDM

Standard and OFDM

FSK-PSK

OFDM

Maturity

Mature, supporteduntil 2025

Mature

in US

Mature

Mature

Mature, lead to WIMAX 2

Mature

Emerging and offered

Concepts like “moving cell”

Matured (N700)

Matured but costly

Matured

Market Support

Until 2025

US

Yes/almost obsolete

Yes

Yes, decreasing

Yes, but moving to LTE

Yes, building standards

Matured

Japan, Europe

Yes, in Europe

Thalys, SNCF

Yes, Flarion