2012

blue

12.1

8.6

10.8

11.0

10.7

7.6

2016

blue

8.8

7.9

8.5

12.3

11.0

9.2

New Mexico

2008

blue

25.5

23.0

27.0

35.1

19.6

24.8

2012

blue

22

24.2

31.0

34.0

25.4

23.4

2016

blue

25.4

30.4

34.2

30.6

26.7

27.5

New York

2008

blue

7.3

7.6

10.3

11.7

9.3

9.4

2012

blue

8.9

9.2

10

14.1

12.4

10.2

2016

blue

9.6

8.5

10.8

12.2

12.1

9.9

North Carolina

2008

blue

14.4

14.9

17.4

19.2

16.0

15.0

2012

red

13.8

15.3

14

23.0

18.4

16.2

2016

red

15.9

14.2

17.7

18.7

19.4

16.1

North Dakota

2008

red

―

―

―

―

―

―

2012

red

―

―

26.0

23.6

―

―

2016

red

―

25.5

25.5

35.1

―

―

Ohio

2008

blue

13.7

16.0

19.0

17.8

13.8

12.0

2012

blue

13.9

16.5

18.1

19.7

17.3

15.1

2016

red

16.2

20.1

18.2

19.7

20.4

16.2

Oklahoma

2008

red

16.4

19.4

22.6

26.0

18.2

17.5

2012

red

22.7

23

26.8

20.3

22.7

18.9

2016

red

30.1

28.4

29.4

29.8

26.4

21.2

Oregon

2008

blue

13.9

14.7

20.5

25.9

21.4

16.9

2012

blue

13.9

20.6

20.0

36.1

21.4

23.6

2016

blue

22.4

16.5

22.7

27.7

25

25.8

Pennsylvania

2008

blue

12.9

15.6

17.1

19.8

14.3

12.7

2012

blue

15.4

15.4

17.8

19.6

17.0

12.8

2016

red

17.2

17.5

19.6

23.6

20.7

16.2

Rhode Island

2008

blue

―

―

17.9

22.2

16.3

―

2012

blue

―

―

―

20.9

―

―

2016

blue

―

―

17.1

20.4

19.7

―

South Carolina

2008

red

16.9

11.9

14.1

19.6

18.5

15.2

2012

red

13.2

16.6

16.4

23.9

19.6

17.8

2016

red

21

18.3

18.9

25.5

22.3

19

South Dakota

2008

red

―

―

22.0

18.8

―

―