2012

blue

12.4

9.6

12.0

15.1

14.3

12.7

2016

blue

10.4

11.3

11.3

14.2

12.6

12.8

Massachusetts

2008

blue

5.7

7.3

12.8

14.2

9.7

7.6

2012

blue

10.5

10.2

13.2

14.7

12.4

7.0

2016

blue

11.2

11.3

12.4

12.5

13.0

8.6

Michigan

2008

blue

12.6

15.8

18.1

18.9

12.6

12.6

2012

blue

15.5

16.2

17.4

18.9

15.3

12.4

2016

red

17.3

16.1

18.1

19.1

18.2

14.0

Minnesota

2008

blue

16.6

12.7

17.1

17.3

14.4

11.1

2012

blue

12.9

12.1

19.2

18.7

17.0

11.2

2016

blue

17.2

18.2

17.6

19.2

18.7

12.1

Mississippi

2008

red

13.8

18.1

17.9

18

18.6

21.1

2012

red

14.3

16.7

22.7

23.1

16.0

16.3

2016

red

16.4

17.5

17.0

17.6

16.3

14.4

Missouri

2008

red

17.3

15.1

17.5

21.0

14.1

15.0

2012

red

18.2

19.2

21.1

22.3

18.7

17.2

2016

red

23.0

26.2

24.5

27.9

21.0

18.4

Montana

2008

red

29.0

36.1

26.5

24.2

22.5

22.1

2012

red

38.8

34.5

26.4

32.7

22.1

2016

red

27.2

44.4

36.8

30.2

28.2

19.5

Nebraska

2008

red

14.1

12.4

18.5

11.6

9.6

2012

red

15.2

13.9

16.8

17.6

17.2

15.2

2016

red

20.8

20.6

16.1

18.3

15.8

9.8

Nevada

2008

blue

23.8

17.9

23.2

35.0

31.1

31.4

2012

blue

13.7

18.9

24.5

31.1

35.0

23.6

2016

blue

18.3

22.7

26.8

30.3

27.3

37.6

New Hampshire

2008

blue

14.6

21.9

21.5

18.7

2012

blue

18.1

18.5

28.6

18.5

13.9

2016

blue

17.4

28.3

22.4

20.4

23.8

New Jersey

2008

blue

8.2

7.8

9.3

10.6

10.0

8.7