S. No.

Optimal Solution

Heuristic Solutions

Value

No. of Iterations

H1

H2

H3

Value

% closeness

No. of iterations

Value

% closeness

No. of iterations

Value

% closeness

1

25.603

1902

24.724

96.57

915

24.841

97.02

1093

26.002

98.44

2

28.389

1686

27.152

95.64

951

27.696

97.56

1136

29.069

97.6

3

23.348

1996

22.579

96.71

989

22.923

98.18

1004

23.766

98.21

4

26.266

1928

25.285

96.27

972

25.968

98.87

1007

27.448

95.5

5

29.317

1602

28.05

95.68

1085

28.479

97.14

1405

30.387

96.35

6

20.429

1897

19.761

96.73

1001

20.046

98.13

1347

20.963

97.39

7

22.95

2070

22.234

96.88

932

22.425

97.71

1054

22.96

99.96

8

24.807

1899

23.992

96.71

908

24.557

98.99

1118

25.76

96.16

9

25.338

1622

24.373

96.19

1010

24.831

98

1139

26.013

97.34

10

27.062

1608

26.063

96.31

992

26.321

97.26

1145

27.328

99.02

11

32.236

1656

31.357

97.27

1008

31.904

98.97

1108

32.354

99.63

12

22.552

1709

21.468

95.19

1035

22.321

98.98

1068

23.08

97.66

13

29.848

1910

29.139

97.62

936

29.201

97.83

1013

30.015

99.44

14

28.787

1868

27.936

97.04

923

28.486

98.95

1030

29.287

98.26

15

33.297

1723

32.311

97.04

1062

32.889

98.77

1195

33.566

99.19

16

27.195

1765

26.619

97.88

1041

26.752

98.37

1396

27.235

99.85

17

36.083

1600

35.041

97.11

1042

35.703

98.95

1400

37.425

96.28

18

38.338

1843

36.598

95.46

948

37.557

97.96

1110

38.432

99.75

19

32.103

1924

30.855

96.11

915

31.371

97.72

1220

33.341

96.14

20

32.501

1997

31.306

96.32

971

31.911

98.18

1217

32.937

98.66

21

32.103

1870

31.091

96.85

939

31.205

97.2

1139

32.999

97.21

22

28.521

1688

27.507

96.44

1038

28.031

98.28

1086

29.194

97.64

23

33.562

1803

31.92

95.11

964

32.767

97.63

1057

34.862

96.13

24

27.991

1921

26.914

96.15

1097

27.475

98.16

1268

28.573

97.92

25

26.399

1789

25.341

95.99

960

26.113

98.92

1257

27.291

96.62

26

30.113

1975

29.22

97.03

1001

29.441

97.77

1301

31.28

96.12

27

31.175

1780

30.248

97.03

910

30.427

97.6

1142

31.648

98.48

28

31.705

1717

30.929

97.55

1083

31.012

97.81

1225

32.16

98.56

29

28.521

1790

27.34

95.86

977

27.817

97.53

1224

28.958

98.47

30

32.103

1739

30.917

96.31

965

31.407

97.83

1230

33.207

96.56

31

31.573

2066

30.315

96.02

1030

30.738

97.36

1154

33.149

95.01

32

33.43

1744

32.073

95.94

1074

32.647

97.66

1191

33.92

98.53

33

36.348

1963

34.536

95.01

949

35.449

97.53

1178

37.078

97.99

34

28.919

1664

27.669

95.68

1076

28.479

98.48

1146

29.306

98.66

35

32.634

1804

31.533

96.63

982

32.021

98.12

1135

32.783

99.54

36

30.379

1772

29.458

96.97

1012

29.954

98.6

1118

30.674

99.03

37

31.573

1920

30.342

96.1

1049

30.833

97.66

1412

32.254

97.84

38

34.624

2033

33.096

95.59

983

34.175

98.7

1051

36.346

95.03

39

33.562

1687

32.627

97.21

1097

32.631

97.23

1210

34.597

96.92