S. No. | Optimal Solution | Heuristic Solutions | ||||||||
Value | No. of Iterations | H1 | H2 | H3 | ||||||
Value | % closeness | No. of iterations | Value | % closeness | No. of iterations | Value | % closeness | |||
1 | 25.603 | 1902 | 24.724 | 96.57 | 915 | 24.841 | 97.02 | 1093 | 26.002 | 98.44 |
2 | 28.389 | 1686 | 27.152 | 95.64 | 951 | 27.696 | 97.56 | 1136 | 29.069 | 97.6 |
3 | 23.348 | 1996 | 22.579 | 96.71 | 989 | 22.923 | 98.18 | 1004 | 23.766 | 98.21 |
4 | 26.266 | 1928 | 25.285 | 96.27 | 972 | 25.968 | 98.87 | 1007 | 27.448 | 95.5 |
5 | 29.317 | 1602 | 28.05 | 95.68 | 1085 | 28.479 | 97.14 | 1405 | 30.387 | 96.35 |
6 | 20.429 | 1897 | 19.761 | 96.73 | 1001 | 20.046 | 98.13 | 1347 | 20.963 | 97.39 |
7 | 22.95 | 2070 | 22.234 | 96.88 | 932 | 22.425 | 97.71 | 1054 | 22.96 | 99.96 |
8 | 24.807 | 1899 | 23.992 | 96.71 | 908 | 24.557 | 98.99 | 1118 | 25.76 | 96.16 |
9 | 25.338 | 1622 | 24.373 | 96.19 | 1010 | 24.831 | 98 | 1139 | 26.013 | 97.34 |
10 | 27.062 | 1608 | 26.063 | 96.31 | 992 | 26.321 | 97.26 | 1145 | 27.328 | 99.02 |
11 | 32.236 | 1656 | 31.357 | 97.27 | 1008 | 31.904 | 98.97 | 1108 | 32.354 | 99.63 |
12 | 22.552 | 1709 | 21.468 | 95.19 | 1035 | 22.321 | 98.98 | 1068 | 23.08 | 97.66 |
13 | 29.848 | 1910 | 29.139 | 97.62 | 936 | 29.201 | 97.83 | 1013 | 30.015 | 99.44 |
14 | 28.787 | 1868 | 27.936 | 97.04 | 923 | 28.486 | 98.95 | 1030 | 29.287 | 98.26 |
15 | 33.297 | 1723 | 32.311 | 97.04 | 1062 | 32.889 | 98.77 | 1195 | 33.566 | 99.19 |
16 | 27.195 | 1765 | 26.619 | 97.88 | 1041 | 26.752 | 98.37 | 1396 | 27.235 | 99.85 |
17 | 36.083 | 1600 | 35.041 | 97.11 | 1042 | 35.703 | 98.95 | 1400 | 37.425 | 96.28 |
18 | 38.338 | 1843 | 36.598 | 95.46 | 948 | 37.557 | 97.96 | 1110 | 38.432 | 99.75 |
19 | 32.103 | 1924 | 30.855 | 96.11 | 915 | 31.371 | 97.72 | 1220 | 33.341 | 96.14 |
20 | 32.501 | 1997 | 31.306 | 96.32 | 971 | 31.911 | 98.18 | 1217 | 32.937 | 98.66 |
21 | 32.103 | 1870 | 31.091 | 96.85 | 939 | 31.205 | 97.2 | 1139 | 32.999 | 97.21 |
22 | 28.521 | 1688 | 27.507 | 96.44 | 1038 | 28.031 | 98.28 | 1086 | 29.194 | 97.64 |
23 | 33.562 | 1803 | 31.92 | 95.11 | 964 | 32.767 | 97.63 | 1057 | 34.862 | 96.13 |
24 | 27.991 | 1921 | 26.914 | 96.15 | 1097 | 27.475 | 98.16 | 1268 | 28.573 | 97.92 |
25 | 26.399 | 1789 | 25.341 | 95.99 | 960 | 26.113 | 98.92 | 1257 | 27.291 | 96.62 |
26 | 30.113 | 1975 | 29.22 | 97.03 | 1001 | 29.441 | 97.77 | 1301 | 31.28 | 96.12 |
27 | 31.175 | 1780 | 30.248 | 97.03 | 910 | 30.427 | 97.6 | 1142 | 31.648 | 98.48 |
28 | 31.705 | 1717 | 30.929 | 97.55 | 1083 | 31.012 | 97.81 | 1225 | 32.16 | 98.56 |
29 | 28.521 | 1790 | 27.34 | 95.86 | 977 | 27.817 | 97.53 | 1224 | 28.958 | 98.47 |
30 | 32.103 | 1739 | 30.917 | 96.31 | 965 | 31.407 | 97.83 | 1230 | 33.207 | 96.56 |
31 | 31.573 | 2066 | 30.315 | 96.02 | 1030 | 30.738 | 97.36 | 1154 | 33.149 | 95.01 |
32 | 33.43 | 1744 | 32.073 | 95.94 | 1074 | 32.647 | 97.66 | 1191 | 33.92 | 98.53 |
33 | 36.348 | 1963 | 34.536 | 95.01 | 949 | 35.449 | 97.53 | 1178 | 37.078 | 97.99 |
34 | 28.919 | 1664 | 27.669 | 95.68 | 1076 | 28.479 | 98.48 | 1146 | 29.306 | 98.66 |
35 | 32.634 | 1804 | 31.533 | 96.63 | 982 | 32.021 | 98.12 | 1135 | 32.783 | 99.54 |
36 | 30.379 | 1772 | 29.458 | 96.97 | 1012 | 29.954 | 98.6 | 1118 | 30.674 | 99.03 |
37 | 31.573 | 1920 | 30.342 | 96.1 | 1049 | 30.833 | 97.66 | 1412 | 32.254 | 97.84 |
38 | 34.624 | 2033 | 33.096 | 95.59 | 983 | 34.175 | 98.7 | 1051 | 36.346 | 95.03 |
39 | 33.562 | 1687 | 32.627 | 97.21 | 1097 | 32.631 | 97.23 | 1210 | 34.597 | 96.92 |