Estimation Method

IV-TSLS

IV-GMM

income growthijd

(1)

(2)

log(incomeijdt)

−0.346***

−0.346***

(0.104)

(0.104)

ageijdt

−0.007***

−0.007***

(0.012)

(0.012)

VDijdt

−0.307

−0.307

(1.395)

(1.395)

log(popdesct)

−0.045

−0.045

(0.754)

(0.754)

Small size

Ref.

Ref.

Medium small size

−0.148***

−0.148***

(0.327)

(0.327)

Medium large size

−0.226***

−0.226***

(0.555)

(0.555)

Large size

−0.216***

−0.216***

(0.619)

(0.619)

Geographic dummy

Yes

Yes

Industrial dummy

Yes

Yes

RVdt

0.894

0.894

(6.210)

(6.210)

UVdt

−0.052

−0.052

(1.154)

(1.154)

lambda

−7.582***

−7.582***

(2.029)

(2.029)

Endogeneity Test(chi-square [p-value])

7.129 [0.028]

7.129 [0.028]

Cragg-Donald Wald F statistics

894.789

894.789

No. of Obs.

83,067

83,067

R-Squared

0.448

0.448

Log Likelihood

−120,235

−120,235

Chi Square

117954.10

117954.10

Selection Equation

No. of Obs.

84,868

84,868

Pseudo-R-Squared

0.015

0.007

Log Pseudo-Likelihood

−8523.46

−8593.29

Wald Chi Square [p-value]

192.36 [0.000]

131.40 [0.000]