Author | Year | Level of Evidence | Country | Average follow-up period | Case procedure (n) | Control procedure (n) | Complications (n) |
Netto et al. | 2012 | Grade II | U.S. | 3 years and 2 months | Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [25] | Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [17] | Case Procedure: Infection [1] Control Procedure: Return of instability [2] |
Mahiroğullari et al. | 2010 |
| Turkey | 2 years and 2 months | Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [30] | Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [34] | Case Procedure: Return of dislocation [1] Control Procedure: Return of dislocation [2] Limitation of external rotation [1] |
Robinson et al. | 2008 | Grade I | U.K. | 2 years | Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopic technique [42] | Capsular arthroscopic lavage [42] | Case Procedure: Recurring instability [3] Erythema [1] Adhesive Capsulitis [2] Mild Restriction [1] Control Procedure: Recurring instability [16] Erythema [1] Adhesive Capsulitis [1] Mild Restriction [1] Other patients: Refractory stiffness |
Andrej Strahovnik e Samo K. Fokter | 2006 |
| Slovenia | 9 years | Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique. Single procedure [83] |
| Single procedure: Return of dislocation [5] Recurring subluxation [5] Stability Failure [10] Laxity without instability [5] |
Jaeger et al. | 2004 |
| Germany | 1 years ans 8 months | T-plasty procedure and Bankart repair [31] | Anatomically oriented and modified anteroinferior capsular change procedure and Bankart repair [31] | Case Procedure: Return of subluxation [3] Dislocation [3] Control Procedure: Isolated Subluxation [1] |
Buscayret et al. | 2004 |
| U.S. | 6 years e 6 months | Coracoid transfer procedure [279]; Open soft tissue reconstruction [217]; Arthroscopic stabilization procedure [74]. |
| At least one procedure performed: Arthritis with onset after surgery [104] |
Jakobsen et al. | 2007 | Grade I | Denmark | 10 years | Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [37] | Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [39] | Case Procedure: Recurring dislocation [3] Pain and stiffness [4] Need for surgical repair [1] Control Procedure: Recurring anterior dislocation [24] Subjective instability [1] Pain and stiffness [4] |
Bottoni et al. | 2002 |
| U.S. | 3 years | Non-surgical shoulder immobilization technique for 4 weeks followed by rehabilitation [14] | Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [10] | Control Procedure: Repair Failure [1] Loss of 4˚ in average external rotation in group [10] |
Zamora-Navas et al. | 2001 |
| Belgium | 13 years and 4 months | Boytchev technique. Single procedure [25] |
| Single procedure: Return of dislocation [5] Restriction of mobility [5] |