Author

Year

Level of Evidence

Country

Average follow-up period

Case procedure (n)

Control procedure (n)

Complications (n)

Netto et al.

2012

Grade II

U.S.

3 years and 2 months

Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [25]

Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [17]

Case Procedure:

Infection [1]

Control Procedure:

Return of instability [2]

Mahiroğullari et al.

2010

Turkey

2 years and 2 months

Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [30]

Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [34]

Case Procedure:

Return of dislocation [1]

Control Procedure:

Return of dislocation [2] Limitation of external rotation [1]

Robinson et al.

2008

Grade I

U.K.

2 years

Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopic technique [42]

Capsular arthroscopic lavage [42]

Case Procedure:

Recurring instability [3]

Erythema [1]

Adhesive Capsulitis [2] Mild Restriction [1]

Control Procedure:

Recurring instability [16]

Erythema [1]

Adhesive Capsulitis [1] Mild Restriction [1]

Other patients:

Refractory stiffness

Andrej Strahovnik e Samo K. Fokter

2006

Slovenia

9 years

Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique. Single procedure [83]

Single procedure:

Return of dislocation [5] Recurring subluxation [5]

Stability Failure [10]

Laxity without instability [5]

Jaeger et al.

2004

Germany

1 years ans 8 months

T-plasty procedure and Bankart repair [31]

Anatomically oriented and modified   anteroinferior capsular change procedure and Bankart repair          [31]                             

Case Procedure:

Return of subluxation [3]

Dislocation [3]

Control Procedure:

Isolated Subluxation [1]

Buscayret et al.

2004

U.S.

6 years e 6 months

Coracoid transfer procedure [279]; Open soft tissue reconstruction [217]; Arthroscopic stabilization procedure [74].

At least one procedure performed:

Arthritis with onset after surgery [104]

Jakobsen et al.

2007

Grade I

Denmark

10 years

Treatment of Bankart lesion by open technique [37]

Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [39]

Case Procedure:

Recurring dislocation [3] Pain and stiffness [4] Need for surgical repair [1]

Control Procedure:

Recurring anterior dislocation [24] Subjective instability [1]

Pain and stiffness [4]

Bottoni et al.

2002

U.S.

3 years

Non-surgical shoulder immobilization technique for 4 weeks followed by rehabilitation [14]

Bankart lesion repair by arthroscopy [10]

Control Procedure:

Repair Failure [1] Loss of 4˚ in average external rotation in group [10]

Zamora-Navas et al.

2001

Belgium

13 years and 4 months

Boytchev technique. Single procedure [25]

Single procedure:

Return of dislocation [5] Restriction of mobility [5]