Authors

Decentralized IoMT Data

Hyperledger Indy

WebAuthn

ZKP for IoMT Data

Blockchain Type

Smart Contract

Blockchain Stored Data

Access Control Method

Data Privacy

IPFS

Li et al. [27]

No

No

No

No

Private and Consortium

Yes

Encrypted health data

AC policies

Encryption

No

Zhang et al. [24]

Consortium

Relevant metadata

ABAC

Asymmetric encryption

Yes

Lin et al. [25]

Encrypted index

CPRE

Encryption technology

No

Attia et al. [18]

Fabric

Medical device data

Not specified

Bai et al. [37]

Other information

Proxy re-encryption

Yes

Abdelgalil and Mejri [11]

Indy and Fabric

Hash of EMRs and access control policy

ABAC

Sun et al. [19]

Ethereum

Hash of EMRs

ABE

Nguyen et al. [20]

Hash value is kept in the smart contract

Smart contract-based

Akkaoui et al. [21]

Hash value

RBAC

Dwivedi et al. [22]

Data hash

Hashing Encryption

No

Buccafurri et al. [23]

Hash value

ABE

A. Nassar et al. [30]

Not specified

Data in Ripple chain

Not specified

Hash-based data storage

Jamil et al. [32]

Vital sign

ACL rules

Encryption technology

Nie et al. [26]

Keyword ciphertext

KPABE

Liu et al. [35]

No

Reserve indexes of EMRs

Content extraction signature

Niu et al. [34]

EMR hash values

ABE

Dubovitskaya et al. [36]

Metadata and protocol for access control

RBAC

Chakraborty et al. [33]

Data hash

Not specified

Not specified

Kumar et al. [31]

Encrypted representation of medical records

Not specified

Data storage using hash functions

Yes

Proposed Solution

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Hyperledgers Indy and Fabric

Yes

Hash of EMRs and secure access control of EMR collected from IoMT

ABAC

Encryption technology

Yes