Item

Stratospheric airship

Traditional airship

Zhiyuan-1

Tianzhou-1

Temperature

−60 - +120

normal

normal

normal

Atmosphere pressure

1/15 - 1 atm

normal

normal

normal

Ozone environment

high concentration

no

no

no

Ion environment

yes

no

no

no

Ultraviolet environment

strong

weak

weak

weak

Flight duration

long time > 24 h

<8 h

<4 h

<4 h

Wind speed

depend on probability and statistics of the wind

constant

constant

constant

Drag coefficient

<0.03 or less

>0.03

0.0283

0.04

Thrust-mass ratio

little

large

little

little

Structure type

non-rigid (rigid partly)

no-rigid/ rigid

non-rigid

non-rigid

Material and structure of the hull

high strength/

large deformation

low strength/small deformation

low strength/small deformation

low strength/small deformation

Ballonet

subdivision

no/fixed

Fixed

fixed

Fin coefficient

about 0.13

0.13 - 0.188

0.13

0.15

Difference of pressure/buoyancy

active control

passive control

active control

passive control

Buoyancy compensatory

yes

no

no

no

Control mode

remote autonomous

remote/manual

autonomous

autonomous

Main energy

solar cell + RFC

fuel/battery

fuel cell + Li battery

Li battery

Propeller

high/low density

high density

high density

high density

Gondola type

external/build-in

external

external

build-in