Group

Satisfaction of teachers’ teaching

Satisfaction of teaching methods

Satisfaction of pleasant atmosphere in class

Excellent Good Bad

Excellent Good Bad

Excellent Good Bad

PBL Group

11/36.67^* 12/40.00 7/23.33^*

12/40.00^* 13/43.33 5/16.67^*

12/40.00^* 15/50.00^* 3/10.00^*

Situational simulation group

10/33.33^* 12/40.00 8/26.67^*

11/36.66^* 14/46.67 5/16.67^*

13/43.33^* 14/46.67^* 3/10.00^*

PBL+ Situational Simulation Group

18/60.00^* 10/33.33^* 2/6.67^*

21/70.00^* 8/26.67^* 1/3.33^*

23/76.67^* 7/23.33 0/0^*

Traditional teaching group

4/13.33 15/50.00 11/36.67

4/13.33 12/40.00 14/46.67

2/6.67 10/33.33 18/60.00