No | Aspect | Sub-district as Local Agency Law No. 32 of 2004 | Sub-district as Non-Local Agency Law No. 23 of 2014 |
1 | Judicial Regulation | In Article 120 clause (2) Law No. 32 of 2004, sub-district is local agency together with regional secretary, secretary of DPRD, local office, regional technical institution, and district. | Article 209 clause (2) Law No. 23 of 2014, sub-district is not a local agency. |
2 | Definition of sub-district | Regulation of Minister of Home Affairs No. 36 of 2007, operational area of lurah as local agency of regency/city is in operational area of district. | It does not specify the definition beside condition for its creation by Regional regulation (Article 229 clause (1)). |
3 | Authority | a) Implementing agency for political decentralization (devolution -Delegation of authority). b) Implementing administrative affairs delegated by regent/mayor (Article 2 Regulation of Minister of Home Affairs No. 36 of 2007 on Delegation of Administrative Affairs of Regency/City to lurah). | Only to the level of district are authorized to implement administrative affairs under the authority of Local government and assisting duty (Article 209 (3)). |
4 | Duties of lurah | Law No. 32 of 2004 a) implementation of administrative activities of sub-district; b) public empowerment; c) public service; d) implementation of public security and order; and e) maintenance of public facilities and infrastructures. Regulation of Minister of Home Affairs No. 36 of 2007 a) Sub-district is operational area of luras as the local agency of regency/city within operational area of District (Article 1). b) Lurah is authorized to implement administrative, development, and social affairs (Article 2 clause (1)). c) Lurah implements administrative affairs as delegated by regent/mayor. (Article 2 clause (2)). d) Regent/mayor delegates administrative affairs to lurah in accordance with the needs of sub-district, by considering efficiency and accountability (Article 3). e) Administrative affairs of regency/city delegated by regent/mayor to lurah are mandatory affairs and optional affairs (Article 5 clause (1)). f) Further provision shall be stipulated in Regulation of Regent/Mayor (Article 5 clause (2)). | Article 229 Law No. 23 of 2014 It is stated that it is to assist camat in: a) implementation of administrative activities of sub-district; b) implementatin of public empowerment; c) implementation of public service; d) maintenance of public security and order; and e) maintenance of public facilities and infrastructures; f) implementation of other duties as delegated by camat; g) implementation of other duties as stipulated; h) in laws and regulations. |
5 | Planning | Entitled with autonomy to make its own Strategic Plan according to public needs. | Not entitled with autonomy to make its own Strategic Plan Strategic Plan is made as part of District’s Strategic Plan. |
6 | Budgeting | Entitled with autonomy to prepare its own budgeting according to the needs and Strategic Plan. | Depending on availability of fund and District’s Strategic Plan. |
7 | Authority | Given by regent/mayor according to the needs of lurah, of both mandatory and optional affairs. | Limited in the implementation of duties given by camat. |