Parameters

ENISA

NIST

OTT

Scope

Broad coverage of cybersecurity threats, including healthcare-specific ones.

General framework applicable to various sectors, including healthcare

Comprehensive coverage, especially for industrial automation and control systems

Granularity

Detailed threat descriptions, suitable for in-depth analysis.

Balanced approach, neither too detailed nor too high-level

Focus on technical threats, may lack granularity in non-technical aspects

Emerging Threats

May not cover the latest emerging threats comprehensively

Provides guidelines for managing evolving risks

May need updates to address emerging healthcare threats

Applicability

Suitable for healthcare but requires tailoring

Relevant for healthcare but not

specific to the industry

May need customization for healthcare context

Alignment with Standards

May align with ISO/IEC 27001 and other standards

Provides overall direction for securing Operational Technology systems

Specific focus on industrial automation security

User-Friendliness

May be complex due to extensive categorization

Balanced and practical for various users

Depends on user familiarity with industrial control systems

Privacy considerations

May need additional privacy-specific criteria

Addresses privacy but not healthcare-specific privacy concerns

Privacy aspects may need customization

Resource requirements

May require significant resources for implementation

Balanced approach considering resource constraints

Resource-efficient but may need adaptation