Protocol

Grid

Network Energy

Energy per node

Messages sent

Energy used

MDSAP

5 * 5

500,000

20,000

40,000

0.72

6 * 6

500,000

13,888

27,778

0.61

7 * 7

500,000

10,204

20,408

0.53

8 * 8

500,000

7813

15,625

0.47

9 * 9

500,000

6173

12,346

0.42

10 * 10

500,000

5000

10,000

0.38

15 * 15

500,000

2222

4444

0.26

30 * 30

500,000

556

1111

0.13

EBP

5 * 5

500,000

Variable

55,556

1

6 * 6

500,000

Variable

45,455

1

7 * 7

500,000

Variable

38,462

1

8 * 8

500,000

Variable

33,333

1

9 * 9

500,000

Variable

29,412

1

10 * 10

500,000

Variable

26,316

1

15 * 15

500,000

Variable

17,241

1

30 * 30

500,000

Variable

8475

1

CEB-P

5 * 5

780,000

Variable

60,000

0.69

6 * 6

805,556

Variable

55,556

0.76

7 * 7

806,122

Variable

40,816

0.66

8 * 8

828,125

Variable

39,063

0.71

9 * 9

808,642

Variable

30,864

0.65

10 * 10

820,000

Variable

30,000

0.70

15 * 15

811,111

Variable

17,778

0.64

30 * 30

896,667

Variable

8889

0.58