Draft ratio

(α)

SPA

DM Method

VR

(m3)

PF (%)

MA step

DT-o

(m3)

PF

(%)

Value

of Φ

DT-e

(m3)

PF

(%)

MT-e

Remark

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

α = 0.90;

SHIx = SHIo = −0.21

SHIo = −0.22

3.30 × 1010

(104.96)*

0.0

MA1

MA2

MA2

1.58 × 1010

2.16 × 1010

2.16 × 1010

9.24

6.53

6.53

0.12

0.23

0.07

2.62 × 1010

3.01 × 1010

3.35 × 1010

5.00

2.54

0.00

82.29

94.75

105.34

MC1, Equation (3)

MC1, Equation (3)

MC1, Equation (3)

α = 0.80;

SHIx = SHIo = −0.41

1.67 × 1010

(52.42)*

0.0

MA1

MA1

MA1

1.27 × 1010

1.27 × 1010

1.27 × 1010

2.42

2.42

2.42

0.98

0.73

0.45

8.42 × 109

1.25 × 1010

1.67 × 1010

5.00

2.58

0.00

26.50

39.30

52.62

MC1, Equation (3)

MC1, Equation (3)

MC1, Equation (3)

α = 0.70;

SHIx = SHIo = −0.62

8.78 × 109

(27.61)*

0.0

MA1

MA1

MA1

9.68 × 109

9.68 × 109

9.68 × 109

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.82

0.44

0.77

2.79 × 109

4.20 × 109

8.87 × 109

5.00

2.58

0.00

8.78

14.21

27.89

MC1, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (3)

α = 0.60;

SHIx = SHIo = −0.82

5.19 × 109

(16.33)*

0.0

MA1

MA1

MA1

5.96 × 109

5.96 × 109

5.96 × 109

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.99

0.60

0.87

1.36 × 109

2.55 × 109

5.23 × 109

5.00

2.42

0.00

4.29

8.03

16.46

MC1, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (3)

α = 0.50;

SHIx = SHIo = −1.03

2.61 × 109

(8.20)*

0.0

MA1

MA1

MA1

3.34 × 109

3.34 × 109

3.34 × 109

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.39

0.26

0.20

3.96 × 108

1.02 × 109

2.63 × 109

5.00

2.58

0.00

1.25

3.20

8.28

MC0, Equation (2)

MC0, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (2)

α = 0.40;

SHIx = SHIav = −1.41

1.05 × 109

(3.31)*

0.0

na**

MA1

MA1

5.38 × 108

7.89 × 108

7.89 × 108

0.00

0.61

0.61

na**

0.90

0.70

1.27 × 107

1.63 × 107 1.09 × 109

5.00

2.58

0.00

0.04

0.51

3.44

By Behavior

MC0, Equation (2)

MC1, Equation (2)