| Draft ratio (α) | SPA | DM Method | ||||||||
| VR (m3) | PF (%) | MA step | DT-o (m3) | PF (%) | Value of Φ | DT-e (m3) | PF (%) | MT-e | Remark | |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
| α = 0.90; SHIx = SHIo = −0.14 SHIo = −0.15 | 4.96 × 109 (64.09)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA3 | 3.29 × 109 3.29 x109 3.67 × 109 | 1.55 1.55 1.20 | 0.73 0.30 0.25 | 1.81 × 109 2.86 × 109 5.00 × 109 | 5.07 2.49 0.00 | 23.42 36.99 64.51 | MC1, Equation (3) MC1, Equation (3) MC1, Equation (3) |
| α = 0.80; SHIx = SHIo = −0.27 | 2.71 × 109 (35.06)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA1 | 2.91 × 109 2.91 × 109 2.91 × 109 | 0.00 0.00 0.00 | 0.53 0.10 0.16 | 7.94 × 108 1.25 × 109 2.74 × 109 | 5.15 2.52 0.00 | 10.25 16.13 35.19 | MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (3) |
| α = 0.70; SHIx = SHIo = −0.41 | 1.79 × 109 (23.12)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA1 | 2.54 × 109 2.54 × 109 2.54 × 109 | 0.00 0.00 0.00 | 0.70 0.35 0.49 | 5.22 × 108 8.34 × 109 1.80 × 109 | 5.07 2.49 0.00 | 6.74 10.77 23.22 | MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (3) |
| α = 0.60; SHIx = SHIo = −0.54 | 1.29 × 109 (16.72)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA1 | 2.17 × 109 2.17 × 109 2.17 × 109 | 0.00 0.00 0.00 | 0.90 0.65 0.67 | 3.01 × 108 4.97 × 108 1.30 × 108 | 5.07 2.49 0.00 | 3.93 6.41 16.77 | MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (3) |
| α = 0.50; SHIx = SHIo = −0.68 | 8.09 × 108 (10.44)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA1 | 1.81 × 109 1.81 × 109 1.81 × 109 | 0.00 0.00 0.00 | 0.62 0.88 0.88 | 1.35 × 108 2.80 × 108 8.16 × 108 | 5.07 2.58 0.00 | 1.75 3.62 10.53 | MC0, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (3) |
| α = 0.40; SHIx = SHIav = −1.18 | 3.07 × 108 (4.77)* | 0.00 | MA1 MA1 MA1 | 3.04 × 108 3.04 × 108 3.04 × 108 | 0.17 0.10 0.17 | 0.82 0.90 0.98 | 5.24 × 107 1.42 × 108 3.71 × 108 | 4.98 2.49 0.00 | 0.68 1.83 4.79 | MC0, Equation (2) MC0, Equation (2) MC1, Equation (3) |