Description

Case study A

Case study B

Case study C

Case study D

Case study E

Case study F

Case study G

Case study H

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

Application domain

MT

MT

MT

MT

MT

PT

MT

PT/MT

MT

Area

M

(automotive)

M

(packaging)

P

(consumer

goods)

P

(wood working)

M

(packaging)

P

(filling)

P

(logistics)

P

M

PLC type and supplier

PLCopen compliant

PLCopen compliant

Siemens S7

Siemens S7,

Rockwell

PLC open compliant

Siemens 1500,

Rockwell

Siemens S7,

Rockwell

PLCopen compliant

Languages

ST, SFC

FBD, ST, SFC

LD

LD, IL

ST

IL

FBD, IL, SCL

IL, FBD

SFC, ST (OO)

Number of components

127

59 + 140

168

133

278

330

356

296

na

na

Number of supplier’s library components

18

140

(16)

-

-

274

74

98

na

na

State machine per module

-

OMAC

-

-

-

OMAC

-

OMAC

Part of engineering environment

Restart after fault

-

(O)

-

-

-

(O)

-

-

na

na

Size of memory [MB]

1.9

14

12.3

0.150

0.580

4.2

0.423

0.218

na

na

Fault handling

I, III

I

II

III

III

I

II

na

na

Maintenance staff

Eng, Tec

Eng, Tec

Tec, SW

Eng, Tec, SW

Tec

Eng, Tec

Eng, Tec

Eng, Tec