Accolade II broach – SP ratio

Taperloc Microplasty broach - SP ratio

CCR

CFI

MCI

CCR

CFI

MCI

Frequency (kHz)

Low

High

P value

Low

High

P value

Low

High

P value

Low

High

P value

Low

High

P value

Low

High

P value

0.5 - 1.0

0.79

(0.58)

0.82

(0.74)

0.947

0.83

(0.74)

0.77

(0.58)

0.137

0.82

(0.61)

0.79

(0.72)

0.531

0.92

(0.24)

0.91

(0.49)

0.749

0.99

(0.43)

0.86

(0.36)

0.749

0.91

(0.43)

0.92

(0.24)

0.848

1.0 - 1.5

0.70

(0.60)

0.77

(0.41)

0.448

0.80

(0.33)

0.70

(0.60)

0.092

0.76

(0.53)

0.71

(0.44)

0.291

1.16

(0.28)

0.77

(0.72)

0.338

0.94

(0.72)

1.1

(0.44)

0.338

0.94

(0.48)

1.16

(0.64)

0.406

1.5 - 2.0

0.75

(0.52)

0.73

(0.48)

0.531

0.79

(0.55)

0.70

(0.55)

0.448

0.74

(0.55)

0.74

(0.52)

0.468

1.01

(0.28)

0.85

(0.4)

0.18

0.85

(0.4)

1.01

(0.28)

0.18

0.89

(0.4)

0.98

(0.3)

0.482

2.0 - 2.5

0.88

(0.68)

0.92

(1.13)

0.248

0.98

(1.13)

0.80

(0.68)

0.013*

0.95

(1.13)

0.81

(0.63)

0.222

0.97

(0.58)

0.86

(0.23)

0.655

0.86

(0.23)

0.97

(0.58)

0.655

0.84

(0.19)

1.04

(0.58)

0.277

2.5 - 3.0

0.94

(0.77)

0.90

(1.20)

0.921

0.97

(1.2)

0.86

(0.77)

0.235

0.85

(0.96)

0.94

(1.2)

0.338

1.11

(0.25)

1.23

(0.74)

0.848

1.19

(0.31)

1.11

(0.72)

0.848

0.97

(0.28)

1.23

(0.61)

0.277

3.0 - 3.5

1.08

(1.35)

1.07

(0.99)

0.552

1.08

(1.33)

1.07

(1.22)

0.692

1.01

(1.33)

1.09

(1.22)

0.306

0.99

(0.4)

0.86

(0.24)

0.11

0.86

(0.22)

1.09

(0.41)

0.11

0.86

(0.2)

1.09

(0.41)

0.018

3.5 - 4.0

1.13

(1.68)

1.23

(0.96)

0.355

1.23

(1.55)

1.17

(1.08)

0.222

1.18

(1.57)

1.29

(1.09)

0.448

1.2

(0.37)

1.07

(0.75)

0.225

1.07

(0.38)

1.2

(0.48)

0.225

1.14

(0.22)

1.2

(0.49)

0.482

4.0 - 4.5

1.25

(1.39)

1.41

(1.65)

0.235

1.40

(1.65)

1.24

(1.39)

0.069

1.40

(1.64)

1.28

(1.64)

0.692

1.71

(0.41)

1.61

(0.79)

0.482

1.61

(0.73)

1.71

(0.44)

0.482

1.73

(0.67)

1.63

(0.57)

0.949

4.5 - 5.0

1.27

(0.97)

1.50

(1.07)

0.051

1.57

(0.81)

1.21

(0.97)

0.002*

1.50

(1.00)

1.30

(1.16)

0.065

1.42

(0.68)

1.3

(0.55)

0.749

1.38

(0.55)

1.3

(0.68)

0.749

1.38

(0.69)

1.3

(0.51)

0.655

5.0 - 5.5

1.79

(1.84)

1.96

(1.71)

0.306

2.08

(1.71)

1.83

(1.84)

0.166

2.21

(1.69)

1.62

(1.84)

0.009*

1.33

(0.59)

1.17

(0.32)

0.277

1.15

(0.32)

1.33

(0.59)

0.277

1.15

(0.34)

1.32

(0.59)

0.225

5.5 - 6.0

1.13

(0.97)

1.18

(0.86)

0.792

1.20

(0.57)

1.14

(1.00)

0.921

1.20

(0.84)

1.13

(0.97)

0.974

1.24

(0.47)

1.42

(0.88)

0.565

1.39

(0.77)

1.46

(0.76)

0.565

1.42

(0.77)

1.39

(0.76)

0.749

6.0 - 6.5

1.03

(1.21)

0.94

(0.58)

0.121

0.96

(0.58)

1.03

(1.21)

0.322

0.93

(0.73)

1.00

(1.21)

0.644

1.04

(0.48)

1.05

(0.3)

0.848

1.06

(0.27)

1

(0.5)

0.848

1.07

(0.51)

1

(0.13)

0.225

6.5 - 7.0

0.90

(0.72)

0.87

(0.49)

0.692

0.82

(0.49)

0.91

(0.72)

0.121

0.88

(0.6)

0.88

(0.74)

0.448

0.95

(0.56)

0.89

(0.36)

0.949

0.95

(0.35)

0.85

(0.56)

0.949

1.12

(0.49)

0.85

(0.25)

0.142

7.0 - 7.5

0.85

(0.85)

0.87

(1.03)

0.552

0.82

(0.56)

0.94

(0.98)

0.013*

0.82

(1.17)

0.94

(0.67)

0.075

1.1

(0.46)

1.26

(0.38)

0.565

1.26

(0.33)

0.98

(0.46)

0.565

1.28

(1.01)

0.98

(0.4)

0.142

7.5 - 8.0

1.39

(1.55)

1.02

(1.42)

0.044*

0.90

(1.09)

1.40

(1.13)

0.001*

1.07

(1.56)

1.24

(1.41)

0.198

0.96

(0.24)

1.35

(0.57)

0.048*

1.35

(0.41)

0.92

(0.17)

0.048*

1.09

(0.53)

0.92

(0.3)

0.085

8.0 - 8.5

1.40

(1.48)

1.10

(1.17)

0.08

1.09

(1.17)

1.44

(1.24)

0.006*

1.12

(1.11)

1.25

(1.54)

0.575

0.98

(0.22)

0.99

(0.42)

0.848

0.99

(0.42)

0.98

(0.22)

0.848

0.99

(0.28)

0.9

(0.32)

0.18

8.5 - 9.0

1.44

(1.41)

1.07

(1.39)

0.113

1.03

(1.39)

1.52

(1.41)

0.023*

1.12

(1.22)

1.32

(1.54)

0.509

1.08

(0.33)

1.1

(0.35)

0.655

1.1

(0.34)

0.9

(0.4)

0.655

1.1

(0.22)

0.84

(0.58)

0.225

9.0 - 9.5

0.78

(0.46)

0.82

(0.63)

0.717

0.74

(0.63)

0.84

(0.48)

0.235

0.81

(0.63)

0.81

(0.36)

0.531

0.85

(0.13)

0.85

(0.43)

0.848

0.85

(0.43)

0.85

(0.13)

0.848

0.85

(0.32)

0.85

(0.52)

0.655

9.5 - 10.0

0.86

(0.71)

0.95

(0.79)

0.019*

0.94

(0.79)

0.91

(0.71)

0.391

0.95

(0.73)

0.91

(0.79)

0.428

0.61

(0.39)

0.57

(0.3)

0.749

0.63

(0.28)

0.54

(0.39)

0.749

0.57

(0.23)

0.61

(0.57)

0.949