Included research

Sample size

Intervention measure

Outcome indicator

Experimental group

Control group

Experimental group

Control group

Liu et al. [10] 2015

85

85

I

II

a

Elli et al. [11] 2016

77

44

I

II

a

Baldinelli et al. [12] 2015

42

48

I

II

a

Lei Wenlan et al. [13] 2016

130

130

I

II

a

Pan Longfang et al. [14] 2015

90

90

I

II

a, b, c

Zhu Ya et al. [15] 2010

65

64

I

II

a

Lin Cuifang et al. [16] 2015

60

60

I

II

a, b

Zhang Ronghua et al. [17] 2015

45

45

I

II

a

Zhou Lianqing et al. [18] 2013

51

49

I

II

a, c

Zhuo Yajuan et al. [19] 2014

60

60

I

II

a, b

Xu Mingming et al. [20] 2012

70

70

I

II

a, b

Jiang Guichun et al. [21] 2016

500

500

I

II

a

Wang Chaohong et al. [22] 2016

43

40

I

II

a, b

Li Xiangjun et al. [23] 2016

98

106

I

II

a

Zheng Chunhua et al. [24] 2016

60

60

I

II

a

Ren Xiaomin et al. [25] 2016

35

35

I

II

a, c