Method

CPM

CNN

0.125

0.25

0.50

1

2

4

8

Average

Zuo et al.

2D

0.672

0.694

0.714

0.739

0.766

0.787

0.822

0.742

Xie et al.

2D

0.493

0.688

0.796

0.852

0.864

0.864

0.864

0.775

Setio et al.

2D

0.636

0.727

0.792

0.844

0.876

0.905

0.916

0.814

Gorkam et al.

3D

0.588

0.669

0.749

0.831

0.863

0.892

0.913

0.786

Dou et al.

3D

0.677

0.834

0.927

0.972

0.981

0.983

0.983

0.908

Ding et al.

3D

0.797

0.857

0.895

0.938

0.954

0.970

0.981

0.913

MP-AFNet (proposed)

3D

0.821

0.869

0.935

0.968

0.971

0.976

0.982

0.931