Study

Country (s)/Periods

Method

Findings

Kraft and Kraft (1978)

United States (1947-1974)

Sims causality test

Unidirectional causality

Yu and Hwang (1984)

United States (1947-1979)

Sims causality test

No causality

Ferguson et al. (2000)

110 countries (1971-1995 and 1960-1995)

Correlation analysis

Unidirectional causality

Shiu and Lam (2004)

China (1971-2000)

Johansen co-integration and Granger causality test

Unidirectional causality

Aktas and Yilmaz (2008)

Turkey (1970-2004)

Granger Causality

Unidirectional causality

Atif and Siddiqi (2010)

Pakistan (1971-2007)

Granger Causality and modified WALD test

Unidirectional causality

Adom (2011)

Ghana (1971-2008)

Toda and Yamamoto Granger causality test

Unidirectional causality

Aslan (2014)

Turkey (1968-2008)

ARDL bond test and Granger causality test

Bidirectional causality

Ogundipe and Apata (2013)

Nigeria (1980-2008)

Bound testing co-integration, linear and no-linear Granger causality tests

Bidirectional causality