Classifications of the Labor and Delivery Assistance Evaluation Sheets

N

Number of midwifery students’ delivery assistance, time ≥ 6 or <6

Crude OR [95% CI]

*P value

Adjusted OR [95% CI]

†‡P value

Average of all 64 evaluation items

≥2.79

<2.79

40

40

11.86 [4.15, 33.89]

Ref

<0.001

19.50 [4.98, 76.30]

Ref

<0.001

Health checkups and assessments of women who give birth

≥2.92

<2.92

39

41

13.78 [4.95, 42.91]

Ref

<0.001

19.09 [5.12, 71.28]

Ref

<0.001

Preparations for labor and delivery assistance

≥2.5

<2.5

48

32

10.52 [3.76, 33.60]

Ref

<0.001

9.31 [2.78, 31.24]

Ref

^§<0.001

Delivery assistance in the parturient second stage

≥2.53

<2.53

39

41

10.33 [3.83, 30.56]

Ref

<0.001

12.68 [3.71, 43.37]

Ref

<0.001

Delivery assistance in the parturient third and fourth stages

≥2.75

<2.75

40

40

22.22 [7.47, 76.43]

Ref

<0.001

28.51 [6.71, 121.03]

Ref

<0.001

Midwifery process

≥3

<3

46

34

7.43 [2.81, 21.50]

Ref

<0.001

12.52 [3.10, 50.52]

Ref

<0.001

The training manner

≥3

<3

47

33

16.33 [5.51, 57.31]

Ref

<0.001

20.49 [5.08, 82.62]

Ref

<0.001

Comprehensive evaluation by midwifery students

≥3

<3

52

26

17.25 [5.11, 80.45]

Ref

<0.001

22.51 [4.25, 119.27]

Ref

<0.0001