Problem Class (Factor A) | Algorithm (Factor B) | ||
Class | Replication of Class | ALNS (Demir) | TDVRPTW (SNRPGA2) |
Random 1 | 1 R1 | 971 | 831 |
2 R1 | 932 | 675 | |
3 R1 | 948 | 717 | |
4 R1 | 1048 | 664 | |
Clustered 1 | 1 C1 | 822 | 593 |
2 C1 | 826 | 567 | |
3 C1 | 827 | 585 | |
4 C1 | 827 | 580 | |
Random Clustered 1 | 1 RC1 | 1207 | 867 |
2 RC1 | 1114 | 771 | |
3 RC1 | 1258 | 847 | |
4 RC1 | 1457 | 811 | |
Random 2 | 1 R2 | 740 | 525 |
2 R2 | 701 | 688 | |
3 R2 | 731 | 590 | |
4 R2 | 794 | 506 | |
Clustered 2 | 1 C2 | 585 | 422 |
2 C2 | 585 | 430 | |
3 C2 | 586 | 432 | |
4 C2 | 586 | 430 | |
Random Clustered 2 | 1 RC2 | 777 | 762 |
2 RC2 | 783 | 573 | |
3 RC2 | 923 | 732 | |
4 RC2 | 962 | 606 |