Herbicide treatmentb | Rate (g・ai・ha−1) | Timing | Black | White | Adzuki | Kidney | ||||||||
Injury 1 WAA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
|
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
|
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1 - 2 tri | 3 | cd | Z | 4 | cde | Z | 60 | fg | Y | 3 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1 - 2 tri | 6 | d | Z | 8 | e | Z | 66 | g | Y | 6 | cd | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 3 - 4 tri | 2 | bc | Z | 3 | bcd | Z | 40 | bcd | Y | 4 | bcd | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 3 - 4 tri | 4 | cd | Z | 6 | de | Z | 47 | de | Y | 8 | d | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 5 - 6 tri | 1 | abc | Z | 2 | bc | Z | 46 | cde | Y | 5 | cd | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 5 - 6 tri | 2 | bc | Z | 3 | bcd | Z | 50 | ef | Y | 7 | cd | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st flower | 0 | ab | Z | 0 | a | Z | 34 | b | Y | 3 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st flower | 1 | abc | Z | 2 | bc | Z | 39 | bcd | Y | 4 | bcd | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st pod | 0 | ab | Z | 0 | a | Z | 31 | b | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st pod | 0 | ab | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 36 | bc | Y | 2 | bc | Z |
Injury 2 WAA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
|
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
|
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1 - 2 tri | 1 | ab | Z | 2 | bc | Z | 71 | fg | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1 - 2 tri | 3 | b | Z | 4 | c | Z | 77 | g | Y | 3 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 3 - 4 tri | 1 | ab | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 59 | de | Y | 3 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 3 - 4 tri | 2 | b | Z | 3 | bc | Z | 68 | f | Y | 4 | c | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 5 - 6 tri | 0 | a | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 56 | de | Y | 2 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 5 - 6 tri | 1 | ab | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 64 | ef | Y | 2 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st flower | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 42 | bc | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st flower | 0 | a | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 51 | cd | Y | 2 | bc | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st pod | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 34 | b | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st pod | 0 | a | Z | 1 | ab | Z | 42 | bc | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Injury 4 WAA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
|
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
| 0 | a |
|
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1 - 2 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 47 | ef | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1 - 2 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 69 | g | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 3 - 4 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 35 | cd | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 3 - 4 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 51 | f | Y | 1 | b | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 5 - 6 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 36 | cd | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 5 - 6 tri | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 47 | ef | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st flower | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 29 | bc | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st flower | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 40 | de | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 35 | 1st pod | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 23 | b | Y | 0 | a | Z |
Halosulfuron | 70 | 1st pod | 0 | a | Z | 0 | a | Z | 29 | bc | Y | 0 | a | Z |