Moves

Steps

English introduction (55)

Chinese introduction (55)

Difference

Number of papers

Percentage

Number of papers

Percentage

Move 1

Establish the research field

1-1 Put forward the central topic

28

50%

22

40%

10%

1-2 Summarize the research content

35

63%

45

81%

18%

1-3 Review previous research results

50

90%

26

47%

43%

Move 2

Establish the research status

2-1Refuting the previous views

6

10.9%

0

0%

10.9%

2-2 Indicating gaps or deficiencies

51

92%

15

27%

65%

2-3Asking questions

4

7.2%

5

%9

1.8%

2-4 Inheriting the tradition of research

1

1.8%

7

12.7%

10.9

Move 3

Occupy the research status

3-1 Overview of research purpose

51

92%

50

91%

1%

3-2 Overview of research findings

46

83%

22

40%

43%

3-3 Point out the structure of the paper

50

90.9%

7

12.7%

78.2%