Scoring | Planning Instruments | ||
Integrated Management of Hydrographic Basins | Territorial Planning in Coastal Municipalities | Marine and Coastal Planning | |
0 | River basin management in coastal areas is done without taking into account “social fairness”; environmental quality in coastal areas is assessed only from ecological perspective, and analysis of costs and benefits are nonexistent; stakeholders within river basins do not perceive the trade-offs stemming from management decisions in coastal river basins. | Land use planning is done without taking into account “social fairness” in coastal areas; coastal environmental quality is assessed only from ecological perspective, and analysis of costs and benefits are nonexistent; stakeholders do not perceive the trade-offs stemming from management decisions of coastal land use. | Marine and coastal planning is done without taking into account “social fairness” in coastal areas, and environmental quality is assessed only from ecological perspective; analysis of costs and benefits is nonexistent in marine spatial planning; stakeholders do not perceive the trade-offs stemming from management decisions of marine activities on coastal areas. |
3 | River basin management in coastal areas occasionally takes into account “social fairness”; environmental quality assessments in coastal areas slightly include economic perspective; analysis of costs and benefits are focused on only one perspective (economic, social or environmental); some stakeholders within river basin perceive the trade-offs stemming from integrated management decisions in coastal river basins. | Land use planning occasionally takes into account 'social fairness' in coastal areas; coastal environmental quality assessments slightly include economic perspective, and analysis of costs and benefits are focused on only one perspective (economic, social or environmental); some stakeholders perceive the trade-offs stemming from integrated decisions of coastal land use. | Marine and coastal planning occasionally takes into account “social fairness” in coastal areas, and environmental quality assessments slightly include economic perspective; Marine spatial planning analyses costs and benefits only for one perspective (economic, social or environmental); some stakeholders perceive the trade-offs stemming from management decisions of marine activities on coastal areas. |
7 | River basin management in coastal areas takes into account “social fairness” in majority of its decisions; decision making enhances environmental quality in coastal areas with regard its impact upon employment and income; river basin management considers the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems, and most stakeholders perceive the trade-offs stemming from integrated management decisions in coastal river basins. | Land use planning takes into account “social fairness” in majority of its decisions in coastal areas, and enhances environmental quality with regard its impact upon employment and income; land use planning considers the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems; most stakeholders perceive the trade-offs stemming from integrated decisions of coastal land use. | Marine and coastal planning takes into account “social fairness” in majority of its decisions in coastal areas, and enhances environmental quality with regard its impact upon employment and income; Marine spatial planning considers the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems; most stakeholders perceive the trade-offs stemming from management decisions of marine activities on coastal areas. |
10 | River basin management in coastal areas has a commitment to take into account “social fairness”; decision making protects and enhances optimum environmental quality in coastal areas with regard to its impact upon employment and income; river basin management considers and negotiates the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems, and stakeholders perceive and understand the trade-offs stemming from integrated management decisions in coastal river basins. | Land use planning has a commitment to take into account “social fairness” in coastal areas, and protects and enhances optimum environmental quality with regard to its impact upon employment and income; land use planning considers and negotiates the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems; stakeholders perceive and understand the trade-offs stemming from integrated decisions of coastal land use. | Marine and coastal planning has a commitment to take into account “social fairness” in coastal areas, and protects and enhances optimum environmental quality with regard to its impact upon employment and income; Marine spatial planning considers and negotiates the consequent costs and benefits for socio-ecological coastal systems; stakeholders perceive and understand the trade-offs stemming from management decisions of marine activities on coastal areas. |