Maturity

age

b

95% confidence limit

P-value

Clockwise or

anticlockwise

Judgment of

slope b

Lower

Higher

1

0.946

0.864

1.027

2.20 (10−16)

Clockwise

b = 1

2

0.800

0.646

0.953

7.10 (10−15)

Clockwise

0 < b < 1

3

0.579

0.369

0.789

8.39 (10−7)

Clockwise

0 < b < 1

4

0.311

0.065

0.556

1.39 (10−2)

Clockwise

0 < b< 1

5

0.050

−0.208

0.308

0.699

Clockwise

b = 0

6

−0.244

−0.494

5.66 (10−3)

5.53 (10−2)

Clockwise

b = 0

7

−0.266

−0.522

−0.010

0.042

Both

b < 0

8

−0.380

−0.608

−0.152

1.47 (10−3)

Both

b < 0

9

−0.124

−0.376

0.129

0.331

Both

b = 0

10

1.04 (10−4)

−0.311

0.311

0.9995

Both

b = 0

11

−0.143

−0.408

0.122

0.284

Both

b = 0

12

−0.241

−0.494

1.15 (10−2)

0.061

Anticlockwise

b = 0

13

−0.098

−0.331

0.331

0.404

Anticlockwise

b = 0

14

0.247

4.12 (10−3)

0.489

0.39

Anticlockwise

0 < b < 1

15

0.390

0.149

0.631

1.96 (10−3)

Anticlockwise

0 < b < 1

16

0.598

0.419

0.776

8.79 (10−9)

Anticlockwise

0 < b < 1

17

0.901

0.755

1.048

2.20 (10−16)

Anticlockwise

b = 1

18

1.147

1.009

1.266

2.20 (10−16)

Anticlockwise

1 < b < 2

19

1.344

1.264

1.423

2.20 (10−16)

Anticlockwise

1 < b < 2

Sardine

0.764

0.634

0.874

2.20 (10−16)

Clockwise

0 < b < 1

Bluefin tuna

0.211

−0.048

0.471

0.109

Anticlockwise

b = 0