No. | Indicator | Score | Expert opinion | Results |
1 | Enterprise talent structure | 0.75 | The absolute value of enterprise employees is not suitable for inclusion in the scoring system | The absolute value indicator is not retained. The proportion of enterprise personnel with bachelor degree or above and the proportion of service developers in the total employees of the enterprise are retained as the specific operation methods of this indicator |
2 | R&D level | 0.90 | Measured by practitioner experience | Retain this indicator, named “Service Developer Level”. The proportion of personnel with more than 3 years of service development experience is used as the operation mode of this indicator |
3 | R&D investment | 0.12 | Proportion of R&D investment used | This indicator is retained |
4 | R&D investment structure | 0.74 |
| This indicator is retained |
5 | Innovation strategy development | 0.58 |
| This indicator is retained |
6 | Innovative institutional safeguard form | 0.62 |
| This metric is retained |
7 | Innovation Institutional Guarantee | −0.25 | Duplication of evaluation content with innovation agency establishment and | This indicator is not retained |
8 | Number and completion of innovation projects | 0.24 | The number of projects initiated reflects the innovation orientation of enterprises, but the corresponding content can be reflected in the innovation strategy section; Innovation outputs are more reflective of project completion | This indicator is not retained strategy development |
9 | Business model for innovative services | 0.78 | The business model should be comprehensively considered in combination with the service content of the enterprise, the establishment of service organizations and the service innovation strategy | Retain this indicator |
10 | Innovation Cooperation | 0.04 |
| This separate indicator is not retained, and the corresponding content is classified as the relevant indicator of “Innovation Institution Guarantee” |
11 | Establishment of external R&D institutions | 0.32 | This separate indicator is not retained, and the corresponding content is classified as the relevant indicator of “innovation institution guarantee” | Partially overlapping with the guarantee of innovation institutions; The establishment of overseas R&D institutions can be used as a bonus |
12 | Information system creation and application | 0.45 | Different industries have different requirements for the use of information technology | This indicator is retained |
13 | Quality management system certification | −0.28 | Industry qualification and certification have the same effect as enterprise awards to a certain extent | This indicator is not retained |
14 | Industry certification | 0.27 | Industry qualification and certification have the same effect as enterprise awards to a certain extent | This indicator is not retained, and the relevant content is reflected in the index of enterprise awards |
15 | Number of honorary titles | −0.09 | Does not fully reflect the innovation ability of the enterprise | This indicator is not retained |
16 | Number of awards | 1.00 | World-class awards should be considered; Provincial, municipal and industry awards can be categorized | Retain this indicator |
17 | R&D investment structure | 0.27 |
| Retain this indicator |
18 | Proportion of output value of innovation industry | 0.12 |
| This indicator is retained |
19 | Proportion of output value of innovative industries | 0. 18 |
| Retain this indicator |
20 | Business revenue from high-tech services | −0.15 | The size of enterprises varies widely, and the absolute value of business income is not suitable for inclusion in the scoring system | This indicator is not retained |
21 | Business Revenue Structure for High-Tech Services | 0.82 | It is more appropriate to measure the ratio of business revenue to total revenue of innovative services, and the rest of the methods are too complicated | Keep this indicator and use the ratio of business revenue of innovative services to total revenue as the operation mode of this indicator |
22 | Core Technology Patents | 1. 00 | Different industries have different tendencies towards patents, copyrights, and copyrights | This indicator is retained |
23 | Copyright and Copyright | 1.00 | The intellectual property rights of many service enterprises are mainly in the form of copyright and copyright, and patents are relatively few | This indicator is retained, and the total number of patents, copyrights and copyrights is treated as a unified indicator |
24 | Level of transformation of scientific and technological achievements with independent intellectual property rights | −0.85 | The level of transformation of scientific and technological achievements can be reflected in innovation outputs | This indicator is not retained |
25 | Application degree of digital technologies in services | 0.57 |
| This indicator is retained |
26 | Degree of foreign participation | 0.65 |
| This indicator is retained |
27 | Overseas R&D institutions | 0.75 |
| Retain this indicator |
28 | Imports and exports of services | 0.38 |
| This indicator is retained |