NO

Author

Country and area

N

Default rate

Study type

Population

1

VAN DER Werf T S (1990) [15]

Ghana

569

10

Retrospective cohort study

Sputum-smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients registered between 1984 and 1987 in a rural ambulatory non-supervised service program in Agogo Hospital in the hills of Ashanti, Ghana

2

Chuah S Y (1991) [17]

Malaysia

227

33

Retrospective cohort study

Tuberculosis patients in Perak started treatment in 1982

3

Menzies R (1993) [18]

Canada

352

16

Retrospective cohort study

Adult Tuberculosis patients treated at the tuberculosis clinic of Montreal Chest Hospital in 1987-1988

4

Me’ndez A P (1997) [66]

USA

184

48

Retrospective cohort study

All patients in New York City with a first-time positive culture for Mycibacterium tuberculosis in April 1991 were selected

5

Ngamvithayapong J (1997) [22]

Thailand

412

26

Prospective cohort study

1) blood donors who had indicated a desire to know their HIV test result; 2) persons attending the hospital’s anonymous counselling and testing clinic; 3) patients attending the hospital’s outpatient clinics for other illnesses but found to be HIV-infected, and 4) female commercial sex workers

6

Jochem K (1997) [24]

Nepal

693

14.8

Prospective cohort study

New cases of Smear positive tuberculosis patients

7

William J (1997) [20]

USA

294

18

Retrospective cohort study

All patients treated with outpatient DOT from 1984 to 1994

8

KATE C (1998) [67]

USA

2576

5.5

Cohort study

Adult patients at least (15 yr of age) reportedas having TB in California during 1993

9

Comolet T M (1998) [27]

Madagascar

149

25.5

Case-control study

Sputum positive tuberculosis patient

10

Tanguis H G (2000) [62]

Spain

2201

13.1

Cohort study

HIV-infected with TB patients between 1987 and 1996

11

Borgdorff M W J

(2000) [63]

Netherland

7529

10

Cohort study

Tuberculosis patient in the Netherlands in the period 1993-1997

12

El-Sony A I (2002) [13]

Sudan

1797

16.9

Cross-sectional study

All persons aged 15 - 49 years with respiratory symptoms seen in the general health services from March 1998 to March 2000,from eight states in Sudan

13

Tekle B (2002) [76]

Ethiopia

1367

11.3

A case control study

New tuberculosis patients on DOTS

14

Edginton M E (2002) [29]

South Africa

303

5.6

A descriptive study

TB patients and community members in the rural Tintswalo district of the Northern Province of South Africa registered with tuberculosis in the 18-month period

15

Santha T (2002) [41]

India

676

17

A community survey

All tuberculosis patients registered from May 1999 through April 2000

16

Chan-Yeung M (2003) [53]

China, Hong Kong

5757

8

Nested case-control study

Patients registered for antituberculous drug therapy in 1996 in Hong Kong

17

Sophia V (2003) [54]

India

483

25

Case control study

New and re-treatment smear positive patients followed up till treatment outcome from March to December 1999 and March 1999 to September 2000

18

Robert M (2004) [21]

USA

372

12.6

Prospective cohort study

Culture-positive patients who were reported from 1998-2000

19

Chang K C (2004) [31]

China, Hong Kong

408

8.5

Nested case-control study

All tuberculosis patients registered at the Government chest clinics from 1 January 1999 to 31 March 1999

20

Hill P C (2005) [42]

Gambia

301

25.2

Prospective cohort study

New cases of TB aged > 15 years who started their treatment between 16 October 2002 and 26 November 2003