Sno

Optimal Solution

Sinha & Sharma Methods

Sharma &Saxena Methods

H1

H2

H3

S2

S3

Sol

Time

Sol

Time

Sol

Time

Sol

Time

Sol

Time

1

19.3

19.01

0.303

19.2

0.489

19.44

0.096

18.62

0.331

18.82

0.489

2

21.4

21.4

0.313

21.4

0.506

21.56

0.1

21.12

0.342

21.34

0.506

3

17.6

17.56

0.306

17.6

0.494

17.73

0.097

17.21

0.334

17.41

0.494

4

19.8

19.72

0.3

19.76

0.484

19.95

0.095

19.66

0.328

19.68

0.484

5

22.1

21.81

0.287

22.03

0.464

22.26

0.091

20.66

0.314

20.88

0.464

6

15.4

15.4

0.309

15.4

0.5

15.51

0.099

15.22

0.338

15.37

0.5

7

17.3

17.27

0.363

17.27

0.535

17.43

0.105

17.2

0.362

17.23

0.535

8

18.7

18.7

0.291

18.7

0.47

18.84

0.093

18.7

0.318

18.7

0.47

9

19.1

18.79

0.3

18.85

0.484

19.24

0.095

17.5

0.328

17.67

0.484

10

20.4

19.97

0.313

20.24

0.506

20.55

0.1

19.22

0.342

19.42

0.506

11

24.3

23.91

0.329

24.11

0.543

24.48

0.107

23.47

0.347

23.69

0.543

12

17

17

0.331

17

0.551

17.13

0.109

16.78

0.362

16.93

0.551

13

22.5

22.41

0.324

22.41

0.553

22.67

0.109

22.01

0.35

22.21

0.553

14

21.7

21.66

0.318

21.7

0.538

21.86

0.106

21.4

0.344

21.44

0.538

15

25.1

24.77

0.327

24.97

0.561

25.28

0.111

24.3

0.357

24.52

0.561

16

20.5

20.5

0.327

20.5

0.554

20.65

0.109

20.5

0.354

20.5

0.554

17

27.2

27.09

0.351

27.15

0.595

27.4

0.117

26.6

0.38

26.85

0.595

18

28.9

28.9

0.322

28.9

0.544

29.11

0.107

28.9

0.348

28.9

0.544

19

24.2

23.79

0.314

23.98

0.523

24.38

0.103

22.39

0.344

23.57

0.523

20

24.5

23.96

0.332

24.13

0.562

24.68

0.111

22.88

0.359

23.74

0.562

21

24.2

23.76

3.012

24.01

4.403

24.38

0.581

23.35

3.389

23.5

4.403

22

21.5

21.48

3.03

21.5

4.43

21.66

0.567

21.11

3.409

21.24

4.43

23

25.3

25.07

2.966

25.2

4.336

25.49

0.599

24.64

3.337

24.79

4.336

24

21.1

21.02

2.911

21.1

4.256

21.26

0.626

20.66

3.275

20.78

4.256

25

19.9

19.34

2.994

19.12

4.376

20.05

0.653

18.65

3.368

18.75

4.376

26

22.7

22.7

2.994

22.7

4.376

22.87

0.631

22.31

3.368

22.45

4.376

27

23.5

23.45

3.213

23.5

4.698

23.67

0.621

23.05

3.615

23.19

4.698

28

23.9

23.9

2.948

23.9

4.309

24.08

0.644

23.9

3.317

23.9

4.309

29

21.5

21.01

2.875

21.16

4.202

21.66

0.639

20.23

3.234

20.34

4.202

30

24.2

23.06

3.04

23.55

4.443

24.38

0.686

22.7

3.42

22.82

4.443

31

23.8

23.3

3.177

23.54

4.644

23.98

0.628

22.9

3.574

23.04

4.644

32

25.2

25.15

3.315

25.2

4.845

25.39

0.621

24.72

3.729

24.87

4.845