| Authors | Year | No. | Ventilation | Rhythm | VE | Position | Responder | Index | Techniques |
| Lafanechère [12] | 2006 | 22 | MV | sinus | 500cc saline | supine position | ΔABF≥15% | cABF-TEE cPP | TEE arterial BP transducer |
| Monnet [13] | 2006 | 71 | MV | sinus/arr | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔABF≥15% | cPP cABF-TEE | arterial BP transducer TEE |
| Lamia [14] | 2007 | 24 | MV/SB | sinus/AF | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔSVI≥15% | cVTIAo-TTE cCO-TTE | TTE TTE |
| Maizel [15] | 2007 | 34 | SB | sinus | 500cc saline | supine position | ΔCO-TTE≥12% | cCO-TTE cSV-TTE | TTE TTE |
| Thiel [16] | 2009 | 89 | MV/SB | sinus/arr | 500cc saline, Ringer’s lactate, HES | semi-recumbent | ΔSV≥15% | cSV-TTE | TTE(USCOM) |
| Monnet [17] | 2009 | 34 | MV | sinus/arr | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔCI≥15% | cCI cPP | PiCCO arterial BP transducer |
| Biais [18] | 2009 | 30 | MV/SB | sinus | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔSV-TTE≥15% | cSV cSV-TTE | Vigileo TTE |
| Préau [19] | 2010 | 34 | SB | sinus | 500cc HES | semi-recumbent | ΔSV≥15% | cSV-TTE cPP | TTE arterial BP transducer |
| Guinot [20] | 2011 | 17 | MV | sinus/arr | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔSV-TTE>15% | cSV-TTE cCO-TTE | TTE TTE |
| Liu [21] | 2011 | 20 | MV | sinus/arr | 250cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔSV≥10% | cSV | PiCCO |
| Wang [22] | 2011 | 33 | MV/SB | sinus/arr | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔSV-TTE≥15% | cSV-TTE cSV-USCOM | TTE USCOM |
| Monnet [23] | 2012 | 39 | MV | sinus | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔCI≥15% | cPPV cPPV-CNAP | PiCCO CNAP |
| García [24] | 2012 | 37 | MV | sinus/arr | 500cc HES | semi-recumbent | ΔCO≥15% | cCO-TEE cPP | TEE arterial BP transducer |
| Monnet [25] | 2013 | 40 | MV | sinus/arr | 500cc saline | semi-recumbent | ΔCI≥15% | cCI | PiCCO |