Treatment method

Suitable for

Advantages

Disadvantages

Reference

Open limestone channels

Pre-treatment or post-treatment

Low operating and maintenance costs, no power consumption, can last for many years, simple and reliable

Coating, long channel required to achieve the desired retention time

[13]

Aerobic wetlands

Acid water containing Fe, Mn and SS

Low operating and maintenance costs, no power consumption, can last for many years

Cannot treat strongly acidic water efficiently

(best for pH > 5.5)

[17]

Anaerobic wetlands

Acid water with low DO, Al, Fe3+ and SS contents

Low operating and maintenance costs, no power consumption, can last for many years

Coating on limestone surface due to presence of Fe and Al, large area and long retention time needed to remove Mn

[17]

Anoxic limestone drains

Acid water with low Al and Fe3+ contents

Low operating and maintenance costs, no power consumption, can last for many years, simple

Needs pretreatment, best for acid water with low DO, Al and Fe3+ to avoid armoring

[14]

Successive alkalinity-producing systems

Acid water with high

contents of metals (Fe, Al, Zn, Cu)

Low operating and maintenance costs, no power consumption, can last for many years

Metal floc accumulation and degradation of organic layer, pretreatment required for acid water with high Fe3+ and SS contents

[14]