X

Technique

Phase

[meV]

X

O

Ref.

28Si

MD

Amorphous Silica

68.8

71.9

[4]

DFT

Vitreous (fused) Silica (v-SiO2)

67.3

64.0

[26]

LD

α-Cristobalite

68.7

66.3

[27]

DFT

α-Quartz

65.2

62.2

[28]

Average

67.5

66.1

ECS

Amorphous Silica

68 ± 2

61 ± 3

[21]

48Ti

DFT

Anastase

47.4

54.6

[29]

TiO2 II* (Columbite)

47.1

54.3

[29]

MI* (Baddeleyite)

48.0

56.2

[29]

OI* (Orthorhombic I)

48.1

57.1

[29]

OII*(Cotunnite)

47.6

57.0

[29]

Rutile

46.3

53.9

[29]

47.3

56.2

[30]

44.8

54.5

[31]

MD

Amorphous Rutile

48.7

58.1

[32]

Rutile Nanoparticle

49.0

58.1

[32]

Average

47.4

56.0

NRPS

Rutile

44.7 ± 2

[33]

ECS

Polycrystalline Rutile

48 ± 2

53 ± 3

[34]

178Hf

DFT

1:7 (4-fold:3-fold) 16O vacancies

42.5

62.5

[3]

ECS

20/60 nm Hf16O2/ Hf18O2 surface bilayer

63±3

[35]